Interactive webcast player

Growth, Infrastructure & Housing Select Committee
Tuesday, 17th November 2026 at 10:00am

 
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Simon Rouse
  2. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Sally Moore - Senior Scrutiny Officer
  2. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Dean Field
  2. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
Share this agenda point
  1. Sally Moore - Senior Scrutiny Officer
  2. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  2. Cllr Simon Rouse
  3. Cllr Michael Bracken
  4. Cllr Dean Field
  5. Cllr Penny Drayton
  6. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  7. Cllr Penny Drayton
  8. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  9. Cllr Simon Rouse
  10. Cllr Michael Collins
  11. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  12. Cllr Simon Rouse
  13. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  14. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  15. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  16. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  17. Cllr Simon Rouse
  18. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  19. Cllr Simon Rouse
  20. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  21. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  22. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  23. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  24. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  25. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  26. Cllr Simon Rouse
  27. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  28. Cllr Simon Rouse
  29. Cllr Mark Roberts
  30. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  31. Cllr Mark Roberts
  32. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  33. Cllr Mark Roberts
  34. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  35. Cllr Simon Rouse
  36. Cllr Frances Kneller
  37. Cllr Michael Bracken
  38. Cllr Frances Kneller
  39. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  40. Cllr Simon Rouse
  41. Cllr Dean Field
  42. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  43. Cllr Simon Rouse
  44. Cllr Michael Collins
  45. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  46. Cllr Simon Rouse
  47. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  48. Cllr Michael Bracken
  49. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  50. Cllr Simon Rouse
  51. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  52. Cllr Michael Bracken
  53. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  54. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  55. Cllr Simon Rouse
  56. Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager
  57. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Penny Drayton
  2. Cllr Michael Bracken
  3. Cllr Simon Rouse
  4. Cllr Penny Drayton
  5. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  6. Cllr Penny Drayton
  7. Cllr Simon Rouse
  8. Cllr David Moore
  9. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  10. Cllr Michael Bracken
  11. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  12. Cllr Michael Bracken
  13. Cllr Simon Rouse
  14. Cllr Mark Roberts
  15. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  16. Cllr Mark Roberts
  17. Cllr Michael Bracken
  18. Cllr Simon Rouse
  19. Cllr Michael Collins
  20. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  21. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Michael Bracken
  2. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  3. Hannah Joyce - Head of Spatial Planning & Climate Resilience
  4. Cllr Simon Rouse
  5. Hannah Austin - Service Director for HIF & Major Projects
  6. Cllr Simon Rouse
  7. James Smith
  8. Cllr Simon Rouse
  9. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  10. James Smith
  11. Phil Houghton
  12. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  13. Phil Houghton
  14. Cllr Simon Rouse
  15. Cllr David Moore
  16. James Smith
  17. Adrian Stearn
  18. Cllr Michael Collins
  19. James Smith
  20. Cllr Michael Collins
  21. Cllr Simon Rouse
  22. James Smith
  23. Phil Houghton
  24. Cllr Simon Rouse
  25. James Smith
  26. Phil Houghton
  27. Jo Thornton
  28. Cllr Simon Rouse
  29. Cllr Caroline Cornell
  30. Cllr Simon Rouse
  31. Cllr Dean Field
  32. James Smith
  33. Cllr Simon Rouse
  34. Cllr Penny Drayton
  35. James Smith
  36. Phil Houghton
  37. Cllr Simon Rouse
  38. Hannah Austin - Service Director for HIF & Major Projects
  39. Cllr Simon Rouse
  40. Cllr Mark Roberts
  41. Jo Thornton
  42. Cllr Mark Roberts
  43. Claire Bayley
  44. Cllr Mark Roberts
  45. James Smith
  46. Cllr Mark Roberts
  47. James Smith
  48. Cllr Simon Rouse
  49. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  50. James Smith
  51. Adrian Stearn
  52. Phil Houghton
  53. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  54. James Smith
  55. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  56. Cllr Simon Rouse
  57. James Smith
  58. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Simon Rouse
  2. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  3. Cllr Simon Rouse
  4. Cllr Gary Hall
  5. Cllr Simon Rouse
  6. Cllr David Moore
  7. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  8. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  9. Cllr Simon Rouse
  10. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  11. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  12. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  13. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  14. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  15. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  16. Cllr Simon Rouse
  17. Cllr Michael Collins
  18. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  19. Cllr Michael Collins
  20. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  21. Cllr Simon Rouse
  22. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  23. Cllr Michael Collins
  24. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  25. Cllr Simon Rouse
  26. Cllr Frances Kneller
  27. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  28. Cllr Frances Kneller
  29. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  30. Cllr Frances Kneller
  31. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  32. Cllr Simon Rouse
  33. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  34. Cllr Frances Kneller
  35. Rachel Emms-Davies - Housing Options Manager
  36. Cllr Simon Rouse
  37. John Holman - Interim Service Director for Housing
  38. Cllr Simon Rouse
  39. Cllr Jonathan Waters
  40. Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability
  41. Cllr Simon Rouse
  42. Cllr Mark Roberts
  43. Cllr Simon Rouse
  44. Cllr Mark Roberts
  45. John Holman - Interim Service Director for Housing
  46. Cllr Mark Roberts
  47. John Holman - Interim Service Director for Housing
  48. Cllr Mark Roberts
  49. Cllr Simon Rouse
  50. Cllr Caroline Cornell
  51. Cllr Simon Rouse
  52. Cllr Penny Drayton
  53. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  54. Cllr Penny Drayton
  55. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  56. Cllr Penny Drayton
  57. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  58. Cllr Penny Drayton
  59. Cllr Simon Rouse
  60. Cllr Penny Drayton
  61. Rachel Emms-Davies - Housing Options Manager
  62. Cllr Penny Drayton
  63. Cllr Simon Rouse
  64. Cllr Dean Field
  65. Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing
  66. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Cllr Robin Stuchbury
  2. Cllr Simon Rouse
Share this agenda point
  1. Webcast Finished

Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:00:00
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:00:15
Welcome to all members of the committee, to officers and members of the public that are
watching the webcast and sitting in the room.
Can I just remind members when you speak to turn on your microphone and switch it off
when you finish speaking so we can make sure that your comments are picked up on the webcast.
Item number one are apologies for absence.

1 Apologies for Absence/Changes in Membership

Sally Moore - Senior Scrutiny Officer - 0:00:35
Thank you Chairman. We've had apologies from cabinet members, Councillor Peter Strachan and Councillor Michael Bracken.
Sorry, Peter Strachan and Councillor Mark Quinn, Councillor Michael Bracken and Councillor Gary Hall are deputising for them.

2 Declarations of Interest

Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:00:54
Thank you very much. Item number two, declarations of interest. Are there any personal pecuniary interests in any of the items on the agenda which members want to declare?
Councillor Field.
Cllr Dean Field - 0:01:07
Yes, I'd like to declare interest on the prison topic because one of my daughters lives on the Spring Hill development.
I've sent the monitoring officer an email. I feel I come here with a clear mind and I'm just waiting confirmation that that's okay.
But Sally's putting her thumbs up so it is. So thanks so much.
Great, thank you Councillor Phil. We'll note that as a personal, not pecuniary interest.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:01:34
Any others? No? Okay. It moves us on to item number three which is minutes of the

3 Minutes of the Previous Meeting

previous meeting. Are people happy to approve the minutes of the previous
meeting? Thank you very much. Item number four. Any public questions that we've

4 Public Questions

received? Sally. Thank you Chairman. We've had one public question from Mr. Tim
Sally Moore - Senior Scrutiny Officer - 0:01:48
Welch. He asks when is the council planning to place the regulation 19
public consultation responses on the local plan into the public domain in
full and by which means.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:02:03
Thank you and we have an answer for Mr. Welch which I will read out and will be
placed in the minutes. So the answer is that the full consultation responses
will be published when the local plan is submitted for examination which subject
to councils approval will be by the 31st of December. The responses will be
electronically on the council's local plan examination webpage. Okay that moves
us on to item number five which is the local plan for Buckinghamshire and here
we're considering a report and examination process for the local plan

5 Local Plan for Buckinghamshire

for Buckinghamshire. I just want to set out for members and for the public the
scope of this item. So the role of this committee is to scrutinise the process
not the contents of the local plan. Council will be meeting in a couple of
weeks to discuss and debate the contents of the local plan and that would be an
opportunity for members here and members more widely to review, to scrutinise
and to speak on the local plan. And so I just want, I think it's important the public
understands that our questions today will be limited to the scope of the
process and the public engagement through the Regulation 19 and I've
members to make sure that they are focused and restricting their comments
to that item of it and as I just wanted to make sure the public understood that
context and just to remind members to confine themselves to that element of
scrutiny. So I'm delighted to welcome council Michael Bracken who's a deputy
cabinet member for planning Steve Bambrick the corporate director for
planning growth and sustainability Hannah Joyce the head of spatial planning and
climate resilience and Charlotte Morris planning policy manager and I think
Charlotte you're going to give us a presentation also Hannah's not here I
I'll just, I apologise, I wasn't even looking then when I read out the names.
Charlotte, I think you're going to give us a presentation to kick off.
Thank you, Chairman.
So today I'm just going to set out using a few slides the process that we're currently within
and the next steps in terms of the examination of the Local Plan.
So we concluded the Regulation 19 consultation at the end of the summer this year and we
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:04:15
have received around 12 ,600 comments.
So we are now in the final stages of responding to those comments, making the individual responses
to those representations and we have set out what we think are the suggested modifications
for an inspector to consider.
So we are currently going through the governance process.
And as part of submitting the local plan for examination,
we're required to carry out what's known
as a PINS pre -examination cheque.
So this is sending it to the planning inspector
for an initial view to make sure
that we are ready to submit the local plan.
And that process has been concluded
And we have received some positive feedback about that.
So we are still on track for submitting the plan by the end of the year.
Last week we had the cabinet meeting where they approved to recommend to full council
to submit the local plan for examination.
And then next week, as the chairman just said, the plan will go to full council for consideration.
So in terms of the local plan examination timetable, we are very much in the hands of
the planning inspector once we submit it to government.
But we anticipate that early in the new year we should be appointed an inspector.
It could be two inspectors.
And then we should receive some initial questions hopefully within the springtime from the planning
inspector.
subject to that we imagine that we will have a series of hearing sessions throughout the
summer months. We anticipate that there will be at least four weeks of hearing sessions.
And then following those hearing sessions we are likely to receive proposed modifications
from the planning inspector. Any main modifications are required to be consulted on prior to the
local plan being adopted. So a modifications consultation is likely then to take place
during the autumn of next year. Before then it is brought back to full council to approve
the local plan for adoption. So we anticipate that the whole process should take around
about 12 months from start to finish once the plan is submitted.
So during the examination there are various roles.
So the inspector will be testing the plan for legal compliance and soundness.
And they will lead the hearing sessions.
And ultimately they will provide an inspector's report
which will conclude whether or not the plan has been found sound.
In terms of the council, we're required to present the evidence and respond to inspector
and questions and just in general support that examination process.
Participants will also be invited to attend the hearing sessions.
So the inspector will identify who should be present at those hearing sessions and participants
can also submit evidence if they are invited to do so by the inspector.
In terms of members you will receive regular updates throughout the process of the examination
and have that oversight.
And as I mentioned, that if there are main modifications,
they will be required to be consulted on prior
to the local plan being adopted.
And so hopefully you're now familiar with the four tests
of soundness, but just to recap, that is to make sure
that the plan is positively prepared, that it is justified
by proportionate evidence, that it's effective and deliverable,
and that is consistent with national planning policy.
So during the examination, we anticipate that there will be several key themes
based on the responses that we've received on the plan.
So this is about the housing requirement and housing supply,
the overall spatial distribution, and in particular the assessment of greenbelts and sites.
There's likely to be questions around the deliverability of our strategic sites and
the infrastructure needed to support those, including transport evidence and affordable
housing and also questions on strategic collaboration.
So this is how we've worked with other stakeholders such as infrastructure providers and our neighbouring
authorities to address those cross -boundaries impacts.
So just in terms of the key messages, the examination is led by the planning inspector.
The submitted plan is the one that was consulted on as part of the Regulation 19 and that's
the one that's examined.
We will receive what's known as issues, matters and questions by the planning inspector and
That's how we respond to those questions as part of that examination.
The process is likely to result in some modifications before it is finally adopted.
And then just on this final slide, it's just highlighting the overall process.
So we must submit the plan for an independent examination.
It's then tested by the planning inspectorate.
They will then decide whether any modifications are required.
A report is then issued to us and then the plan goes back to full council to approve it for adoption.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:10:09
Councillor Bracken, anything you want to add?
Cllr Michael Bracken - 0:10:12
Yeah, I think just to, I hope that was helpful in terms of laying out in the future.
I wanted to go a little bit sort of backwards looking as well.
Because I think the fact and the level of engagement we had
in the Reg 19 consultation exercise should be welcomed.
I think that is a good achievement for the council.
And in fact, in the paper you'll see we tracked all the
engagements that we've done and the various numbers.
And I think that as a council,
I think we have absolutely done what we should do in trying
to ensure that the public can have essays.
I think that's very helpful.
I think the other point just
to bring out was the very positive engagement
of the team has had with pins and those feedback sessions and I think you know
certainly I take a lot of comfort from knowing that in the run -up to hopefully
approval by full council next week and then submission that we have got
everything lined up in the way it needs to be. Thank you. Questions? Councillor
Drayton.
Cllr Dean Field - 0:11:16
Thank you. I don't know if the slides can go back up it might be helpful
for my question for the timeline one, but not to worry if it's a problem I'll ask
Cllr Penny Drayton - 0:11:25
anyway. On the timeline, you had it started in January, that's it perfect
thank you. You got January appointment of the inspector in January to March
inspector review. There's a couple of parts to the question, mainly starting on
the January point, do we know for sure we're going to get an inspector assigned
in January or what is the window, when's the latest inspector might be assigned
and what is the impact, is there an alternative timeline if that is the
situation, if the inspector doesn't get assigned until later. So obviously the
the outcome of that if that's the case would be that it pushes everything back.
So just the understanding of that might be that you can tell me
that would definitely go on January, that's fine.
Presuming if that's not the case,
is there any leniency then for us on the sort of deadline,
if it's the assignment of the inspector
which has caused a delay?
And my final point was not, I've got a few notes,
but I'll keep it short.
Can we try really hard to avoid doing consultation
during summer holidays because it seems that they
always seem to fall in summer holidays
and that upsets a lot of people.
So we've got it down there as September to October,
but obviously this is indicative.
Just a comment on the side, if we can avoid summer holidays,
I think people will appreciate that.
Thank you.
Shana.
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:13:04
So I cannot give a definitive answer of when we will get
an inspector.
We're very much in the hands of pins when we submit.
However, we think it is likely that we
will receive an inspector at the start of the year.
So their guidance notes actually says that we should
have an inspector appointed within three weeks
of submitting.
However, we do know that lots of local plans
are being submitted at the same time.
So we can only work on what we know,
but we are hopeful that we will get an inspector
within that first month.
Just on your second point in terms of consultation,
again, we will be very much led by the planning inspector
and their availability and when those hearing sessions occur.
So we will obviously be mindful and try to do our best to make sure
that their consultation doesn't fall within that peak summer holiday period.
But again, very much we are in the hands
of the planning inspector once that plan gets submitted.
Sorry, thank you.
Cllr Penny Drayton - 0:14:02
So just to clarify, you did answer thank you that you're expecting in January,
but my question was what's the window and how does
that affect an alternative timeline?
If we didn't get one appointed in January,
do we get the opportunity of our deadline being pushed?
And when is the latest one might be?
As you say, you've been told three weeks,
and we'd hope and expect that.
But if that isn't the case, is there an alternative timeline
that you're going to have to squeeze everything into?
So, we anticipate the whole examination would take a year,
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:14:38
But obviously if we don't get an inspector appointed straightaway, then that will have a knock -on effect
And the deadline for us to submit is still by the 31st of December
So that deadline doesn't change and that's that's a fixed date for us
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:14:57
Okay, Councillor Collins
Cllr Michael Collins - 0:15:00
Thank You chairman
Are there elements of the plan where you feel the inspector may require additional clarification,
which in due course will then delay process?
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:15:17
So the purpose of the examination is for the issues to be discussed,
and that's a series of written representations but also hearing sessions.
So that's all part of examining the plan and making sure that it is sound
And so that's why it's anticipated that it will take approximately a year
to go through the various matters for them to be heard but also
for a response to be made in terms of
modifications and for those to be consulted on
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:15:51
Okay, council waters
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 0:16:00
That's not deliberate, I promise you.
Could we get a replacement mic?
Do you want to grab that one?
It was working earlier, wasn't it?
Okay, this one is.
Sorry. I have a couple of questions.
One is, the first one is looking backwards,
though most of the presentation was looking forwards.
During the process, the Regulation 19,
there were quite a number of documents that were not delivered at the time when it was
initially released.
One, what were the main causes of that and did we feel, or did you feel that though they
were late, that it affected the process in any way in a negative manner?
It's my sort of first question.
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:16:59
So there were four pieces of evidence which were published later than the start,
by the 23rd of July when the Reg 19 started.
And they were for a mix of reasons.
One was just an administrative error.
That was for the Greenbelt Assessment, Appendix 7, to the main Greenbelt report.
The others were due to being appendices of appendices and we didn't know, we didn't think they were appropriate to be published but we were then asked questions about it.
So we responded positively and made them available for everyone.
And consequently, each piece of evidence which went onto our web page
past the start date was then extended so that it was made available for at least six weeks.
And the six weeks is what the legal requirement is.
We felt it was beneficial, so we received 74 comments specifically in relation to those bits of evidence.
And so we are confident that they had opportunity to comment on those pieces of evidence and
that's formed part of our consultation response which is appendix 1 to the cabinet papers
that were published last week.
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 0:18:19
The second question is the looking forward and obviously the key part I suppose is thinking
as you get the questions coming back from the inspector and you're developing the answers
to that as a council.
Will Growth, Infrastructure and Housing Committee get an opportunity to be involved at that
point in the process so that we can feed in and review some of those points because, or
is that something where we're not going to see that or have any opportunity to actually
sense cheque what's going in?
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:18:57
So I think the answer to that is it's unlikely and I think probably no that we'll be in a
position to bring back reports to this committee or any other committee for that matter through
the process. You'll have seen no doubt in the cabinet papers part of the decision making
that we're seeking is for appropriate delegations to be put in place in order for the council
to be able to respond as quickly as possible.
There'll be an expectation from the inspector
and that the inspector themselves will set deadlines
when they ask questions for responses to be submitted.
In some cases, when we are actually
in the examination hearings,
some of those responses will need to be turned around
very quickly, i .e. either on the day or within 24 hours,
which is why those delegations will be appropriate.
I think, through you, Chair,
I think there probably are regular updates
that we've got scheduled to come to GIH which would effectively as I see it be
at those various points updates on where we are in the process but I
don't anticipate we'd be in a position where we'll be bringing substantive
papers on policy choices that we might be making through the examination. Okay
so it's after the case thank you. Thank you can I just before can I just quickly
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:20:15
come back on one of Councillor Waters questions which was the late the items
that were added slightly after the start.
And you referred to 74, I think I heard you right,
74 responses.
Just to prep that a little bit.
So when the inspector looks at the consultation responses,
do they look at it through a lens of the themes
that are raised rather than the weight of the responses?
So in that scenario where they were like,
even though there were, whether 74 is a lot or not,
will they look at it and say, OK, these
are the themes that I just want to test, rather than there
were only 74 rather than 1 ,000?
Because I think that's the bit that would just
confidence that there is sufficient input from the public because the themes
won't necessarily be different if it's 74 versus 200 I guess. That's correct so
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:21:00
the inspector will be looking at what they consider the main issues to be so
they won't be going through every single comment that is made in relation to
every topic it will be those ones which are the more contentious issues that
they'll be delving into more detail.
But in terms of the representations that were made
for what we call the late evidence,
they will be treated exactly the same
as the other representations.
Great, thank you.
I've got Councillor Stachbury next.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:21:28
And thank you, Chair, for the opportunity to ask them,
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 0:21:33
there's no doubt this, as you say in your report,
we had 12 ,600 representations to the consultation,
which is probably the highest we've had on anything.
And living in North Buckinghamshire,
I was about to say a portion of the campaign came from there.
One of the things I think your timeline looks really optimistic,
because we don't control the process,
we don't control the interpretation of the inspector
or UCEDD inspectors.
And within your report you recognised the housing,
social housing, questions around green belt,
questions about not having a green belt,
and all those challenges.
and I think that just to ask why you're so certain
that that timeline for the first question,
and depending on that there's a second one,
you're so certain that that will take place in that timeline.
I can't see it.
Chair, again, just to be clear,
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:22:31
and as the slide says that's on the screen,
this is an indicative timetable.
We can't give you any certainty around the timetable.
But what we can tell you is because we've been doing the advisory visits with the planning
inspector as has been referred to, we've obviously taken advice from the inspector as to what
they perceive to be the likely timetable.
And of course, they and we as well will have experience and be able to see what other local
plan timetables look like.
Now having said that there is of course the possibility that as we get into the examination
an issue or issues are raised that require further evidence or further hearings that
elongates the timetable.
At this stage we're not saying we are anticipating that, we're saying that based on all the evidence
available and the advice from the inspectors this indicative timetable is
broadly what we would expect to see but once we get into it that could change.
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 0:23:42
Thank you. You say in your report about modifications well we don't know
what the inspector will choose to come back for modification some of them could
be very large modifications around infrastructure drainage sewage and stuff
which we all know the issues.
We don't know that.
So, and in your response to Jonathan,
you said you don't anticipate coming back here.
If the time lag of this plan goes on,
as other plans have done in the past,
which means they drift quite a lot further forward
than the anticipations in your aspirations,
there really needs to be timeline then for examination
because whether you live in South Buckingham
and North Buckinghamshire, you will have want to have a level of scrutiny.
I think that's something we need to do because I've seen lots of challenge to it.
I think we all have and I think the modification timeline.
And lastly, if it just goes back for modification and it's delayed, does it then,
and you may know this, I don't, will it then fall under, if it comes back under the MPPF 2026
because it will have been delayed and it will then fall under the current legislation which
offers, I think it's just one thing in it, 40 % affordable housing, which isn't in the
MPPF 2024. So if it comes back, will it be under that legislation, which is a whole new
way of looking at the plan? And I don't know the answer to that, so I'm asking officers
who should do.
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:25:18
So under the transitional arrangements for plan making,
what's known as the old regulations, the test is to submit by the end of this year
in order for it to be examined against the 2024 MPPF.
So in answer to your question,
the time that the examination takes does not have an impact on the MPPF
of which it is assessed against.
So even if there are delays, it will still continue to be assessed
against the 2024 MPPF.
Lastly, how do you substantiate that answer?
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 0:25:49
Because we don't know the timeline it's going to drift.
So you're saying that optimistically,
that we hit all these things in a proximate way.
Legislations change, always changes.
That's the sort of part answer.
I would put challenge to that, that it may well be
looked at under the new thing.
I'm not really getting an answer that says it won't be.
I mean, I think it probably quite positive in some ways
it was but but you know I'm not getting reassurance I need on that thank you.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:26:22
To be as clear as we possibly can the reason why we are on a timetable to
submit by the 31st of December is because the government have been clear
for those plans that hit that timetable which as you've seen today we are on
track to do then no matter how long the examination then subsequently takes the
plan will be examined under the previous MPPF there will not be any changes
thereafter so the the deadline for us the 31st of December is critical for
that purpose we will then continue through the whole of the examination no
matter how long it takes to be examined at the 2024 MPPF I hope that's clear so
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:27:05
I think that was clear and I think that's been clear all the way along while
We were hitting the timeline because it's become one counts as touch was first point though, which is
My understanding or our understanding has been that all the way through the process through up to regulation 18 through regulation
19 is you've been working with planet with the planning inspectorate in a review and challenge basis around the plan
Have they also been involved in a review and challenge post the regulation 19 therefore giving us some confidence around
The readiness to address the themes that counts as touch. We was flagging
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:27:39
So, the pre -examination cheque, which I referred to earlier, was specifically looking at the
Reg19 version of the plan and the comments that we've received on the plan since then.
So, we had a meeting, an advisory visit in October this year, which was for that purpose.
And so, we have received positive feedback on the latest version of the plan at that
visit.
Thank you. I've next got Councillor Roberts.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:28:05
Cllr Mark Roberts - 0:28:09
Yes, I've got a couple of points and I'd just like to pick up on some of the things that have come up already.
In particular, the topic of the timeline is particularly relevant.
The Inspector will set the timeline. My understanding is that other examinations take longer than 12 months.
So we've got this timeline here.
The question is around which are the elements within this.
Have you got, what's your degree of confidence
about the different elements of this?
Because it seems to me that elements like the amount
of time for hearings or the consultations on modifications,
that they may be the areas where there might be less confidence
in that timeline than on other elements
and that would have a consequent risk to the timetable.
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:29:01
So ultimately it would depend on the number of issues and matters
which the inspector considers need to be assessed in more detail.
So that will then have an impact on, firstly, the number of questions that are asked,
which will then influence the number of hearing days which are required.
So I'd say four weeks would be a minimum.
There may be more than that.
In terms of the modification consultation, that will need to be for a minimum of six weeks,
so the same as any other consultation for the local plan.
But you're quite right.
This is the best case scenario timetable, but there are lots of variables within it.
We do know, though, that the planning inspector have put in additional resource to get these plans through,
because obviously we are one of many local plans who are submitting at this time.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 0:29:52
If I may, one thing I'd just like to clarify, Chair, is that Councillor Waters raised about
report back on the issues and decisions. I think Mr Bambrick highlighted that, that the
decisions would be taken under delegated authority. That would be the expectation. But just to
clear I'm understanding that we at this committee would at least get a report
back of the decisions that have been taken for us to be able to after the
event scrutinise and ask questions about the basis on which they were taken is
that correct?
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:30:42
Sorry, yes, so Chair Aga and again, I think this committee has, as I mentioned earlier,
a series of scheduled meetings throughout the year and we will bring updates at various
points and at those points where we can give you give updates to this
committee about progress with the examination and inputs that we've had to
the examination even if we haven't got an outcome at that stage and then of
course we'll be very happy to give updates to this committee I think the
other point just to be very clear on in terms of the role of this committee so
as you can see on the slide on the screen though there is a decision for
Council at the end at the end of the process. So once the examination is
concluded we will receive an inspectors report and in effect the the baton gets
passed back to the council at that stage to make a decision about adoption of the
plan and of course what you see on the slide is a decision of council to do
that there will be a governance process as normal that will that will lead up to
that council decision which I anticipate this committee will have a role in.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 0:31:52
The last point I wanted to raise was really around the representations that we've
received so obviously a large number of representations the the update we've got
today talks about the number of those representations but not clearly what
thought the content of those representations was.
So it echoes the public question that was raised
as to when will we get to see the content of those
and what the key themes were that were raised
and how that was, in particular,
how you officers went about assessing that
in terms of assessing which modifications have already been included.
There's obviously been some assessment.
How was that judged?
What criteria were used to determine which modifications you've already reflected into the plan that's going to be presented to Council?
Thank you.
so
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:33:02
you've obviously heard the the answer to the question today in terms of the actual publication of all of the
detailed comments and responses to that but just just specifically in relation to
how we've
considered those responses so you'll have
Again, it's been referred to today cabinet met last week and as part of the cabinet papers
appendix one to the cabinet papers sets out the statement of consultation and that does set out the key
themes that come out of the consultation and the council's response or proposed response to those key themes and that has
helped inform the
draught modifications that are also
Proposed as part of the cabinet decision and the proposed council decision for next week
Thank You cancer Nella
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:33:51
Cllr Frances Kneller - 0:33:54
Thank you, Chair. Members and the public are aware that the Council is under pressure to
get this plan submitted before the end of December. But we understand, or I understand
that the Housing Minister confirmed that Council is already subject to a specific submission
direction can make individual requests for that direction to be amended. I
understand from the cabinet meetings that there is still an amount of ongoing
work that needs to be addressed before we're ready to actually submit the plan.
So my question is basically have we asked the Minister to amend our
submission date in light of the work that there is still under preparation
and how can members be satisfied that the deadline of the 31st of December is
not driving the decision on whether the plan is actually ready for examination
if we still got an amount of work that needs to be addressed. Thank you. Happy to
Cllr Michael Bracken - 0:35:07
say that. So we are we are pressing under a direction to submit
By the end of the year so that three month additional period would not apply to us
So, you know, we are therefore required to go for 31st
December I think in terms of you know readiness
I think if you have had an opportunity to review went to cabinet last week
You will see an enormous amount of detail work that has been done
Closer to that than others. So I mean I think we are on track
But ultimately that will be a decision for the full council next week because all of that information will obviously be able to that to be
There to inform that decision of the council
Cllr Frances Kneller - 0:35:47
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:35:54
Yes, I
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:35:56
Can confirm I saw a complete row of nodding at that as well and good
I've got cancer field and then I'll come back to counts Collins
Cllr Dean Field - 0:36:04
Hello, I noticed you got 12 ,600 and you said you're going through all the responses as you talk as time goes on.
But what percentage are we at the moment regarding with the responses?
And I think 12 ,600 representations,
is if it shows that what you've done, my opinion,
is the consultation work.
So be it through parish councils or for yourselves.
But yeah, I'm just interested to find out what percentage
are we at the moment with the replying
to those representations.
Thank you.
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:36:49
So we have gone through every single comment
that has been made.
So that 12 ,600 or so comments.
So we have considered all of them and we have provided a response for all of them.
But importantly we have now produced what Steve referred to as a statement of consultation.
So that's the legal requirement that we are required to do to set out for the main issues.
And that's quite important so it's not every single issue, it's what we consider the main
issues to be and our proposed response to them.
So that process has been completed and as part of that process we are proposing some
suggested modifications and they are placed into two categories, minor which tends to
be like formatting changes and main where there's a change to the policy.
So within the statement of consultation Annex A there's a schedule of these so that was
made public for cabinet and I believe for tomorrow papers will be made public for the
council meeting next week.
So that process has now fully been concluded.
Thank you.
Councillor Collins.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:38:00
Thank you, Chairman.
Cllr Michael Collins - 0:38:03
The government requires to provide 91 ,000 houses
going forward.
If the inspector decides not to approve our plan,
what is our legal status?
Do we have the right to challenge,
or are we back to the drawing board?
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:38:25
So obviously there are a number of different potential outcomes as part of the examination
process so clearly our preferred outcome is the inspector finds the plan in its current
form sound with perhaps some very few modifications. There's an alternative scenario which the
inspector seeks so rather more modifications but still finds the plan
sound with those modifications. I think I mean there's that there could be a
further and we've talked about you know potential delays there could be a
further scenario where the inspector asks for more work to be completed and
in effect kind of pauses the examination process for that for that process to
follow I think in exceptional circumstances and it is increasingly exceptional but it's
still nevertheless possible that the inspector could find the plan not to be sound and in
those circumstances the council remains in a position where it therefore no longer has
an up -to -date local plan. It would be a matter for council then what it then does with that
I mean whether or not we'd obviously need to consider whatever the inspector has said
in making that decision before we choose what the next steps are but ultimately the council will need to think about progressing a
New local plan as quickly as possible
Because as you've heard us talk on many occasions the absence of an upstate local plan
Leaves the council and the county vulnerable to speculative
Schemes, so the sooner we have an upstate plan better
Okay, I'm going to take
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:40:01
You always do it to me Councillor Stachowy. I was about to say I'm going to take Councillor Waters and then I'm going to wrap up with a couple of questions.
I'll take Councillor Waters, Councillor Stachowy and then I'll wrap up.
Thank you Chairman, I don't normally come back for a second.
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 0:40:14
I've been looking at this timetable and it's slightly in my head.
Being one of the councillors in the south of Buckinghamshire where the Greenbelt and natural landscapes are so important.
and the time scales here as we haemorrhage week by week more and more speculative sites
coming in and Steve Bamberg has just mentioned the speculative sites.
At what point within this time scale will we start getting a level of or an ability
to start defending against Greybelt those sites because at the moment I
think if you were in Becklesfield or Iver or any of these areas week by week
you're going a year is going to be a very long time if it goes on much longer
than that a hell of a long time so be really good to get a feeling of at what
point do we get something which we could start defending the areas which this
plans supposedly is going to crystallise for us.
And that would be good.
Thank you.
I think that point has already been reached.
Cllr Michael Bracken - 0:41:27
So there is already limited weight to the plan.
So there is already some protection.
And as you know, through to the end of the adoption process
is when we would, I would argue, we would have, you know,
close to 100 % of that.
But we are on that, already on that path.
Well, sorry, we've got an application we're going to
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 0:41:45
this afternoon and strategic sites and there is not a single mention of that in that report
so maybe you should be talking to the officers. Thank you.
Okay, Councillor Stutchbury.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:41:54
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 0:41:56
Thank you, thank you. Partly what Jonathan said, there's a huge amount of challenge out
there at the moment, speculative applications. We need to be able to delineate between the
plan, the specked applications, the tilted balance and where we are, because people confuse
all these things together and there needs to be some sort of expression around that.
The reality is though that the duty to cooperate and we don't know what the adjacent authorities
challenge will be because I'm not, I can think in my own area of two areas where
we butt up to other areas and how we manage that and I want some assurance
about what pre -conversations has taken place like the South North Dance and
Milton Keynes Council about our plan because they'll have their plan and
and there will be some conversation about working business, working relationship.
What you hear is, might be true or not true, I want to reassurance that we are in a business,
especially on infrastructure in North Buckinghamshire, you couldn't have any more,
those two councils are very key to that infrastructure because, you know, the river doesn't respect county boundaries
and neither does the highway and the transport links
just to make sure that we are in that basis
because I worry that during the process
we didn't really talk to them in my knowledge
or we didn't have a lot of conversation about that.
That is going on while we're in this transition period
in this optimistic hope of getting the plan
through in this timeline.
So that is not true.
Cllr Michael Bracken - 0:43:53
We have been engaging with the neighbouring authorities
and in fact my colleague will just work through the de -set of what we have done.
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:44:02
So as well as processing all the comments for the local plan a key area
of our work has been to engage with our neighbouring authorities and that's to
set out areas of agreement with them and areas which are unresolved so that the
Planning Inspector knows what the key issues are. So as part of the cabinet
papers and what will be the council papers. We're also publishing a strategic compliance
statement and within that we have a series of statements of common grounds. So that sets
out all the engagement that we've had with our neighbouring authorities right from the
start of the plan preparation up to now. So it's not just our neighbours, it's also with
what are known as prescribed bodies. So people like the Environment Agency, Natural England,
highways, England, all of those really important bodies, there's a clear audit
trail of all the engagement that we've had to date and so we recognise that
that's really key. I think just to clarify the duty to cooperate has
actually been revoked, however under national planning guidance there's still
a requirement for strategic collaboration and that's what this
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 0:45:14
compliance statement sets out. Thank you for that response. Can you at a time
which is appropriate through the chair bring back some information and I think
it should go through the chair about how that conversation took place then we
could decide whether it's something we can discuss and not discuss because I
don't want to discuss it and prejudice the plan but I'd like to understand the
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:45:35
what took place. So to be fair Councillor Stutchbury it's in the cabinet papers and it
therefore I assume will be in the papers that go to council so council will have
an opportunity to scrutinise that part of it but it is very clear in the
Cabinet papers what's been done on that so I don't necessarily think it needs to come to this committee because I think that's part of
What we need to decide at council next week when we upon on the plan. That would just be my my comment
Can I just wrap up with so firstly? Thank you for what's been a long session particularly. Thank you Charlotte
Who's taken the brunt of the questions? We've got two questions and then one observation
so
12 ,600 responses
Instinctively feels like a lot of responses
but I guess my question is have we benchmarked how that would compare to
other local plans to give ourselves confidence it's been a sufficiently full
consultation and then the second thing is so I have read the cabinet papers and
I what is clear in the appendix one is the key themes that have been raised and
a very clear set of responses to the themes I think confidence about the
process isn't just has the public had enough time to scrutinise and put in
comments which I think we've explored today but also have you had enough time
to properly consider those responses and provide really consider responses can
you just give us a degree of confidence about how have you run that process in a
way that can give us confidence you've had sufficient time yourselves to
properly scrutinise the answers not just token review the answers and that leads
me to my kind of third observation which is what I constantly make which is for
me this isn't just about the process of getting to submission of the plan it's
how from beginning to end we've built public confidence in the way that we've
developed the plan and I think what's quite striking from the statement of
community involvement when you look at it in the appendix is just how much has
been done since the beginning of this process to get input across a whole
range of areas from the design code to you know the regulation 18 to regulation
19 and I think we probably have we have I thought I had certainly had not taken
in all of that activity and I'm therefore confident the public won't
taken in all of that activity and so as part of the stage between now the
process of the big special looking at it I think it would be helpful for the
council to think about how it could communicate to the public just how much
engagement and involvement there has been in shaping the plan so that it
genuinely feels like something that's evolved because it does go back a long
way and it does involve the whole set of things that when you you know you're not
looking at the you know you're looking at individual parts you will miss that
bigger picture and I think there is a communications opportunity for the
So just how you might take that idea forward, but those two questions and that observation.
Thank you, Chairman.
Charlotte Morris - Planning Policy Manager - 0:48:12
So taking your first question in terms of benchmarking the number of responses received, so we have around 4 ,000 representations, so that's individuals or organisations,
and of those 4 ,000 representations, there's about 12 ,600 comments.
So we know typically that large authorities, particularly where there's green belts,
which tend to be more contentious, an average number of representations is between 2 ,000 to 4 ,000 representations.
So we are within that normal range, but the upper end is what, which given the size of the authority, I think we would expect that.
In terms of having enough time to fully consider responses,
we are confident that we have gone through each and every comment in detail
and responded on an individual basis.
Now, in terms of what we're actually required to do,
it's actually just to set up the main issues and response to those main issues.
However, we have felt that in order to make sure that we have been thorough,
we have provided a response to every single comment that has been made.
And that's what will become public once we submit the plan.
In terms of communicating the various stages of the plan, you're right, it has been going
on for several years.
The very first stage was actually what we called an exploratory stage, which had its
own consultation about what the priorities should be for the local plan.
We then had another consultation on the vision and objectives.
Then we had what was called the Reg 18 local plan which had draught policies and sort of strategic approaches for development
This year we've actually had a site engagement exercise as well as the formal regulation 19
And so actually in the statement of consultation within the introduction section
It does set out clearly the different stages of consultation
But we certainly take that away in terms of the messaging to make that make that clear to our communities
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:50:13
I just think the public aren't going to read cabinet papers and see that and so I think there's a sort of a
Retail communication bit to think about I think just help build confidence in the plan
Okay. Thank you very much been a very thorough and useful session and thank you for taking all the questions
I'm going to suggest councillor Bracken
That we save you the pain of sitting through the rest of the meeting for item eight
And while we're here, we'll do your elements of the performance monitoring if that's okay
It's fine but let's jump into because we've got we've got a few minutes before

8 Performance Monitoring Report Q2 2026 to 2027

the next item so I'm gonna move us to item eight if we can just do the planning
portfolio performance report any questions on that whilst we've got
Councillor Bracken? No? Oh I've got one. Councillor Drayton?
Cllr Penny Drayton - 0:51:01
Sorry I do have questions I was just getting to the right part in the agenda
The concern on the performance within the planning departments,
there's an application which myself
and colleagues were querying the other day and we were told
by officers that they are still so shortly staffed
that they just can't get round to getting things done.
This particular one has been pending for, I think,
it's just over a year and the earliest it's going to be looked
at now is January, we were told as the earliest it's going to be looked at. So, what we're hearing
is there is still serious concern. I mean it is acknowledged that there is problems but obviously
the last meeting I couldn't attend, I was unwell, but through the minutes and reviewing of it,
it was covered that this is all coming into hand but it doesn't seem to be. So, just really an
update on how it's been addressed because there still seems to be a problem with recruiting
and getting on top of applications.
So I think obviously the specifics of that one,
Cllr Michael Bracken - 0:52:14
perhaps we could take that up offline
just because that doesn't sound welcome
and shouldn't be taking that long.
So please do write to me specifically on that one.
I think in the general, what I've seen
in working with the team is that there is
significant progress towards improving turnaround times,
Clearly, it is a multiyear process, I think, to get to the goal that we want.
But we have been very clear that our goal is that applications that are well -founded have all the elements prepared and submitted at the time that they go into submission should be going through on the statutory period.
And so from the internal information that I've seen we are now working through
Blockages in the system such that a higher percentage of things are going through on that original
Statutory time period as I think that isn't that isn't a process that's going to be transformed overnight, but I do think we are on track
towards improving the situation
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:53:20
Thank you put my head down and look at them suddenly those hands got up I've got a council waters first
Sorry, can I, sorry.
Cllr Penny Drayton - 0:53:27
Just so just on clarity that you we have now got full staffing and we're not still trying to recruit because you feel we are
in a position that
We don't need it
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 0:53:37
So we like all services across council. We will have some vacancies. We don't have
you know, we don't have a
Any number of vacancies that are of concern so, you know where we have turnover of staff we are
you know recruit those to those roles and we are still seeing as I say today
the ability to fill those roles so we're not in a place where we are necessarily
struggling albeit I know that there's the national picture is that there is a
an overall shortage of planners that's particularly in some levels of seniority
though those happen but but we're not we're not seeing that across the board
In booking I'm sure in terms of our recruitment process. We have seen a considerable spike in applications
which has been partly let because of the
Increase in fees so that was a there was a particular spike
earlier last year which meant
but with people trying to get applications in before the fee increase hit and
And we're seeing some of that wave also go through the system as well
which is obviously adding to some workloads across the
Across the department, but we are not seeing
Any significant issues in relation to recruitment?
Cllr Penny Drayton - 0:55:01
Okay, thank you, I will raise the one which
Council Bracken did because but it's not an isolated incident. We're witnessing quite a few still. Thank you
Cllr Simon Rouse - 0:55:11
I just need a very quick come for break. So councillor Moore is going to chair while storm out. He's got the names in order
Cllr David Moore - 0:55:17
Thank you, Chairman. Thank you, Councillor Drayton. I now move to Councillor Waters.
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 0:55:23
Thank you. It's really on the same point because I know we still have a lot of things which
are not being dealt with and a number in my ward and people who still contact me across
other wards. So we're not really out of the difficulties that have been there. The thing
it actually shocked me and actually shocked some of the officers when they saw it, was
I think it was like, I think it was 1 .8 million surplus within the current year on the department,
which comes from applications fees, but we have been unable to deliver against the applications.
And that was in the finance document at Cabinet.
So it's a public figure, I think it was 1 .8, might be 1 .6,
that we didn't get hold of things at an earlier stage.
And it's absolutely right that Steve Bambrick states, yes,
the number of applications was significantly high.
But with significant number of applications,
you get a paid service to deliver against those applications.
We did not bring in quickly enough the teams and the contractor team.
So we've created a surplus misery and cost for applicants with inflation.
So they're waiting a year or more for their permissions, some still waiting.
And it seemed to be okay that that's actually is pretty horrendous.
And what we've put the staff through has also been horrendous,
which I raised last time.
But when I saw that figure, I was thinking, well,
we must have not had any money in the budgets.
We've had to be tight.
So basically what we've done is we've created a surplus
on the amount of applicants not getting their applications dealt
with properly, and that seems to be acceptable.
And we still haven't really solved the problem.
You're talking a lot of confidence,
but that's not what's coming through on the ground.
So I'm not particularly happy with what sits there.
It would be great to actually see this getting
in line and pretty quickly.
Cllr Michael Bracken - 0:57:36
Well, Councillor, you are picking up exactly the issue that I've been discussing with the officers for some time, I agree.
And I think we have been working with the officers on how we can scale the process.
But I think it's not just a matter of throwing bodies at it.
I think there are lots of elements of this process that we can do better and we have been working through improvement plans on.
and so I do think we are on the case.
I also think, you know, if you look across the budget
of the council as a whole, we do have to balance
the overall budget, not just this department.
So there are some other pressures that we need to sort of
think about in the round, but the thrust of where
you're going with that, I'm in full agreement
and that is exactly what we've been working
with the officer team on.
Councillor Stutchfield.
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 0:58:27
Thank you, thank you, and thank you, Councillor Bracken,
you're a regular attender at these meetings now,
more so than the cabinet members, I thank you for your attendance.
The point being with this, there's a lot of stuff in these figures saying,
you know, off -target percentages,
but it's looking where this is a slot in time
and just living where I do, we've got thousands of houses working their way through the process,
which are not in the Buckinghamshire plan, they're not in the neighbourhood plans,
and they're not in the suspected applications chap.
That takes time in the office and they are some of the most contentious applications.
I'm not sure that I'm getting that we've got enough resource to manage those.
Why we're trying to produce a buck and chip plan, which we discussed earlier, why we're
trying to do all the other things, I want reassurance that there is enough resource
in the office because with this planning system as it is now in the tilted balance, we know
how challenging those applications will be, especially where I live.
can you give me some reassurance that that's being monitored,
that if we do get to a point, we can get some more support
in the office, because once you start tailing backwards
with this stuff, you then get to the point that applications
get determined for non -determination,
and we don't get a chance for officers
to professionally examine them.
So I worry about that.
So I just seek some reassurance for you,
the deputy cabinet member that that's being monitored.
I'm not making an accusation that it isn't happening.
I worry that it could happen.
Cllr Michael Bracken - 1:00:21
I think we can give that reassurance.
We obviously looking ahead,
we're mindful that the service needs to scale up
in anticipation of what is in the local plan
that you have seen.
So that is something that where we look out further
that we are planning for that.
I would again, they go back to what I was saying earlier,
this is not just a matter of throwing bodies
at it, there are many things that we can do in our processes and indeed our culture to
be more effective.
You know, in my own commercial background, I often took the view that a job is as easy
to do on time as it is to do late.
And in fact, in most instances, it's easier to do it on time.
So if you can remove blockages in the system that are causing you to run over time, actually
that makes your life a lot easier.
And so I say it is not just a matter of the total resource that needs to be deployed.
It is also about working culture and working effectiveness of the team
that is going to deliver an improvement in the service.
Thank you.
Councillor Roberts.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:01:24
Yeah, I think I'd just echo some of the comments of colleagues
Cllr Mark Roberts - 1:01:30
around the issues that are arising around applications.
I had a case this week in my ward of a resident who'd paid for a pre -application service,
had not received the service, got fed up waiting and had gone ahead with submitting their application
without having had the pre -application.
That potentially has knock -on effects for how that application then progresses.
We regularly get inquiries about what's the status of a planning application that people
haven't heard about or wondering what's going on.
I think the thing with that is it's generating extra workload for the applicants, for the
officers who are having to deal with those inquiries and members that are chasing up
about what the status is of applications.
So it is a regular occurrence.
So I take on board, I just want to support the comments of others on that.
In your report, in the monitoring, it refers to Development Management Improvement Plan
and you've also referred to Service Improvement Plan elsewhere.
But I'm not sure that we've actually seen a documented plan, seen that document, if
it exists as a document that you could share about actions and timetable.
I just wondered if you could clarify that because I think
that would be something that would give us reassurance
if we were able to see the improvement plan that's being
pursued and then have that subject to testing and make sure
that presentation is about its progress.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 1:03:27
So I think I'm very happy to share that information more broadly and I think as part of that improvement
plan one of the aspects of that will be a more robust process of kind of member engagement
in not only what the service is doing but also the improvements that's being delivered
So I think as part of that, very happy to share the detail around the plan.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 1:03:52
Yeah, if we could note that because I think that would give members a lot of reassurance
that about how the situation is being dealt with and what the future might hold for us on that.
And in particular also as you alluded to about the future,
what the service needs to look like to deliver the local plan.
Cllr Michael Bracken - 1:04:13
If I could just add one thing I think we probably should recognise is that as members we are
the ones that are always going to have problems put in our face, right?
We're going to see all the problem issues.
So the absence of the people who were very happy with the service in your inbox is not
unexpected.
If I could just take the opportunity to also encourage members to always to use the mechanisms
that we have available in the system to help chase down those problems.
The planning surgery specifically, that is normally the most common thing
I've been advising members to do.
And I would encourage people to share details with me and others as well.
I do find that troubleshooting some of the issues that we've coped
through the system is exactly the kind of work that is helping us
to identify blockages and so on.
So I personally have found it very useful working with the team
to see those slightly more formal processes than just a chasing email.
It really does actually help shape what we're doing within the service.
Thank you.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:05:20
And finally, Councillor Collins.
Yes, thank you, Chairman.
Cllr Michael Collins - 1:05:24
Beyond the MPPF, it's felt that planners often lack local knowledge,
which may have a negative effect on the decisions they're taking.
And I think the imperative that the planners that we use,
some of them are subcontract agents, people,
actually I often feel that they don't even know where Buckinghamshire is.
And I just wonder how we address those issues, because it's imperative.
We have the wellbeing of our residents to consider,
and often I think decisions are taken without knowledge
of the actual site situations.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 1:06:06
So I think if there are any specific cases then we're always happy to look at those but I think the mechanisms we have in place both in terms of our recruitment processes but also in terms of our decision -making processes means that no one decision is signed off by any individual officer.
So there are further kind of senior sign -offs to make sure that we're making appropriate
and professional decisions.
So but as I say, if there are any specific cases that members have got concerns over,
then we're always happy to look at those.
Just to pay that up directly with the cabinet member and Steve.
Right.
We'll move on to item six.
can ask people that are presenting on that item you want to come forward and
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:06:53
take a seat
Great, thank you.
So we're moving on to item six, which is the new prison at Grendan Underwood.
And just for the benefit of the public, we are considering the new prison at Grendan
Underwood as a major infrastructure project and to help us assess the impact on the local
community.
We've had reports from officers and from the Ministry of Justice who are here today, along
with a representative from the principal contractor.
Given there are so many individuals,
if we could start and ask everybody
to introduce themselves, their name and their role,

6 New prison at Grendon Underwood

and I'll start with Councillor Bracken and work along.
Cllr Michael Bracken - 1:08:00
I'm Councillor Michael Bracken.
I'm the Deputy Cabinet Member for Planning.
Hello, Steve Bambrick.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 1:08:09
I'm the Corporate Director
for Planning, Growth and Sustainability.
Hannah Joyce - Head of Spatial Planning & Climate Resilience - 1:08:12
Hi everyone, I'm Claire Bailey.
I'm the service director for planning and environment
Morning all I'm Hannah Austin. I'm the service director for infrastructure and major projects
Morning everybody Joe Thornton highways development manager
Good morning. I'm Adrian Stern project leader for Langer walks the main contractor
Good morning, James Smith
I am the senior responsible owner for the new prisons programme which includes the new prison at Grendon and a worker HMP BS
Good morning all my name is Phil Horton I'm the principal project sponsor within
MOJ property. Good morning everybody I'm Phil Cronshaw I'm the programme director
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:08:56
working to James on the new prisoners programme. Great thank you welcome everybody
so I think we're going to kick off with the presentation from officers and then
I'll hand over to representatives from MOJ.
Who's kicking us off?
Yeah, I will.
So we're here today to provide an update on the new category C prison development at Grendan Underwood.
And the council's ongoing role in overseeing its delivery.
Importantly, colleagues from MOJ and their principal contractor for the project are in attendance today.
Hannah Austin - Service Director for HIF & Major Projects - 1:09:38
And just I would note that that is largely kind of voluntary.
This wasn't an item that we were asked to bring to the committee, but rather colleagues from MOJ
asked us how they could better engage with our members and
Hence the item being here today
So members will recall that Buckinghamshire Council refused the original planning application in March
2022 due to concerns including sustainability landscape and heritage impacts biodiversity issues and the loss of playing fields
Following a public inquiry, the Secretary of State granted planning permission in January 2024,
concluding that although the scheme conflicted with elements of the development plan,
the national need for prison places and the wider social economic benefits outweighed those concerns.
The approved development will provide a new prison accommodating up to 1 ,468 prisoners,
together with the associated infrastructure, parking, landscaping and support facilities.
Subsequent approvals have been secured for both the detailed appearance and landscaping of the site,
and the construction traffic management plan known as CTMP2.
The principle of the prison has been established by the Secretary of State and cannot be revisited through the condition discharge process.
The Council's role and how we see our role is to ensure that approved mitigation measures are delivered, monitored and enforced where necessary.
Understandably, local residents, parish councils and ward members continue to express concern
about construction traffic, the use of Lawn Hill in particular, highway safety, impacts
on pedestrians, cyclists and equestrians, as well as cumulative impacts alongside HS2
works.
And that's the reason why both the planning service and infrastructure and motor projects
service are involved with this project.
The approved construction management plan 2 includes a range of controls designed to
to investigate these impacts, including agreed routing,
vehicle movement limits, speed controls, wheel washing,
road condition monitoring, traffic ambassadors,
and a complaints management process.
Monitoring information received to date indicates compliance
with the improved arrangements
and regular coordination meetings are taking place
between the MOJ, HS2, Buckinghamshire Council.
The construction programme will extend over several years,
making ongoing monitoring, communication,
and community engagement critical,
and officers will continue to review compliance,
investigate concerns raised by residents and take appropriate action where evidence demonstrates
that intervention is required. Engagement with the MOJA has been positive to date. The project
team are really responsive and they want to be a good neighbour to the community. Thanks.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:12:12
Thank you. Who's opening up? Thank you. Thank you. Really appreciate the opportunity to update the
on the progress of delivery at the new prison.
The committee would have seen our report,
which provides an overview of the project
and the stages of which we're at and which we will deliver.
The new prison at Grendon is an all electric new prison.
It's a category C resettlement prison,
providing 1 ,500 much needed prison places.
The design of the prison aims to help prisoners
prepare for release into the community
through a variety of education, training and work facilities in a secure setting.
Following the reserve matters approval in October 2025, early works have commenced on site.
This will be followed by a substantial enabling works programme to prepare the
ground and infrastructure before the construction of the prison itself is started.
It's a complex site and it's still very early days but we're on track to deliver by 2031
in line with the government's commitment to deliver the remaining 14 ,000 prison places.
I'd like to thank and put on record our thanks to the council officials for the constructive
and collaborative dialogue and work they've done with us particularly in working through
highways and traffic implications and concerns.
We recognise that securing approvals is not by any stretch of the imagination the end of the process.
James Smith - 1:13:52
Compliance, effective monitoring and engagement ongoing is crucial.
We also recognise the strength of feeling locally,
particularly the impact of construction and the cumulative impact of multiple major projects in the locality.
That's why we sought to engage extensively with residents, local ward and parish councillors
to ensure that they know what is happening, when it's happening and act on any concerns
wherever and whenever we can. We're committed to continuing that engagement at all levels
to making sure we adhere to the conditions of our construction development and the traffic
and the wider coordination with other major infrastructure projects like HS2. We also
want to ensure there's a lasting legacy and benefit to the local community and we're seeking
to do that through employment, apprenticeships and business involvement and building on what
we've seen at other new prison sites to deliver wider social value to that local community.
So I'll end there and say thank you once again for the opportunity to update you on our plans
and look forward to the discussion and the questions that you have.
Thank you.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:15:02
Councillor Stutchbury.
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 1:15:05
Firstly, thank you, Chair, and thank you for coming today.
Firstly, I visited the prison some years ago when I was Mayor in Buckingham, and I recognise
that the need to create prison places nationally is a very important subject and the need to
actually have proper accommodation for prisoners is very important, that said.
I have no interest in being a resident in the prison, that said as well.
As I declare no interest in becoming a resident of the prison, just to get that out there
in case there's any disbelief about that.
But that said, I am a well -known resident of North Buckinghamshire, I understand the tick.
I am really concerned that in the delivery phase of this needed facility in rural North Buckinghamshire,
the infrastructure around it, the convertivity to it, the road which comes from the Buckingham End
the road coming in the other end is basically an agricultural
track which has been widened with no under over various
years just to keep it wider. And we do have all the other
traffic which you kindly referred to with all the other
construction works going on. I don't think over and above the
application being agreed. The infrastructure round there is
have a robust infrastructure and it's
maybe robust enough when it's open but it isn't robust enough
now. So I want some comments on how you're going to do something
to improve that infrastructure because
without that being improved, the site
James Smith - 1:17:11
becomes less viable, less tenable and the effects on the
introduction we we absolutely understand the strength of feeling in the impact
locally from the construction that's why we've worked really closely with the
council officials in developing that construction traffic management plan
which sets out exactly how we're going to manage the construction impacts on
the site through the various construction routes that we're using so
our focus now is really on monitoring and making sure we're complying with
that construction management plan.
And obviously as part of that, we're seeking to ensure
that we mitigate the impacts on the roads.
And if there is detriment, put that right.
I may, Phil, you may want to come in as well in terms of some
of the practical ways of which we're doing that.
Sure. Thanks, James.
Yeah, so a couple of things I'd just like to highlight as well.
So we would be doing, we do photographic survey work
so that we all understand the condition of the roads,
both at the beginning, at the end,
but also at periods in between.
And we'll continue to monitor that.
Phil Houghton - 1:18:20
We've already had some discussions with HS2
on multiple topics, but this topic is one of them.
And we want to stress that we understand our responsibilities.
I think the other thing I would say,
as well, is that effectively, for us
to be able to deliver our project
and deliver in a timely fashion, we also
need to ensure that those roads are in good condition so that our contractor can get on
and do their work. So actually it's kind of, it's in our best interest as well to ensure
that. So we continue to monitor that. We continue to monitor the condition and we will be doing
that on a regular basis as well throughout. So obviously we've referred to how long this
programme is. We're conscious of that. So that's an ongoing thing really.
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 1:19:10
Just to come back on that briefly, with developments you only can spend money adjacent to the actual
development.
You will have known when you've worked through your plan that many of the issues are not
directly next to the prison.
You've got them lovely pillars outside which I suppose will disappear, and the road up
there, and there's no – and you are building in a residential area of places which were
once prison officer accommodation.
So it's a residential area that you'll be constructing this in.
Phil Houghton - 1:19:45
So I think what I would flag,
and so for instance Spring Hill Road for instance,
you know, we've built an access point off Grendan Road directly
so that we are not going up Spring Hill Road.
Obviously that took some time for us to do that,
but that route, that access point is now in place.
So we have sought to reduce the impact on those residents of Spring Hill Road.
Obviously, we're aware of the impact on Lorne Hill residents and we know that.
And that's why we will make sure that we continue to monitor the condition of that road
as well as the roads leading up to the prison from the A41.
But we have in terms of, I don't know how many households are on that Spring Hill Road estate,
but there are quite a number and we have taken our construction site away from them to the
left of them to try and reduce the impact somewhat.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:20:37
Okay, thank you.
Councillor Moore.
Thank you, Chairman.
Cllr David Moore - 1:20:40
I know, obviously, the construction programme is 306 weeks, which is a long time.
So we have to get these HGV movements right.
So what do residents are expected to do when things go wrong?
So ultimately, if you're going to have a construction break
of that length, you're going to have certain HGVs take the wrong
roads, take the wrong routes.
You know, if they're speeding, if they're causing damage,
what do residents do?
What is the reporting in place?
And how can that be obviously applied to the CTMP compliance
and to ensure that HGVs and construction traffic are
respecting the local area?
Thank you.
Thank you.
It's a really helpful question.
James Smith - 1:21:26
And so essentially there's a variety of ways and methods.
One of the things we've introduced at site is a traffic marshal or traffic ambassadors,
you heard them being referred to.
So that provides an onsite visible presence for both monitoring purposes but also for
dialogue and engagement of residents if there are concerns.
So I may bring Adrian in in a second for a bit more detail as well.
But as well as an overall programme or project we have a dedicated mailbox which can be used by residents locally if they have concerns which fall outside of any of that or if they want to raise concerns via that route as well.
What I would say is that you know we take our we take our obligations really really seriously.
We absolutely understand the impact of the project locally.
That's why we've put in place through the CTEMP a variety of measures
to ensure that contractors are complying with the routes and the speeds
and that we robustly monitor and enforce that.
Do you want to come in here, James?
Thanks, James.
Yes, so once we have the approved CTMP,
we instal a system called Datascope,
which is our vehicle delivery management software to the project.
And any of the constraints that are defined in the CTMP are transferred into this online portal.
All of our suppliers then that want to bring vehicles to the project via our logistics management team
Adrian Stearn - 1:23:01
that manage the portal can then only select delivery slots using the preferred routes as defined in the CTMP
at time slots within the given day so that our logistics management team controls the number of vehicles
that attend site in any given hour,
and we make sure we spread them across the day,
and also that we avoid the rush hours.
So in our CTMP, we have an agreement
to try and avoid the first couple of hours in the morning
when people are going to work and going to school,
and the last couple of hours in the evening
when people are coming back from work.
And so we distribute our slots
on our management system accordingly,
so that controls that.
We monitor the compliance via this data scope,
so as vehicles arrive to site,
We cheque what route they follow to the project.
We take their registration and vehicle details.
We cheque their compliance with some of our accreditations
that we request from our suppliers.
And then we produce a monthly report that we share
with the MOJ and with Bucks Council
to demonstrate the compliance to the CTMP.
So to date, we're about 99 .5 to 99 .8 % compliance to the CTMP.
So we aren't perfect.
There was a situation a couple of weeks ago
where there was some improvement work that's been undertaken
at the A41 junction.
And that led to a couple of vehicles
and the drivers trying to find a different route
to get to the project.
They then deviated from the preferred route.
We then took that up with their company seniors.
They then retrained those drivers.
And then the companies that were involved positioned their own
staff along the designated routes to monitor the compliance
of their vehicles for the next couple of days
until the A41 improvement works were finished and removed from site.
Councillor Collins.
Cllr Michael Collins - 1:24:44
Thank you, Chairman.
I understand the Ministry of Justice will carry all of the costs during and up to the completion of the prison.
However, do we see a situation that once the prison is complete,
the residents of Buckinghamshire will be expected to carry other costs?
We have examples within parishes where the parish councils are subject to additional costs
because of development within their patch that are not covered by their precepts.
And I just wonder ongoing these things to come on with this some kind of system in place to enable those costs to be covered by the county.
But also I feel that at various points during the development it will be beneficial to the committee maybe to have the odd site visit to enable us to better understand where we are with the development.
Because I think that would be extremely beneficial,
enable us maybe to ask the right questions at the right time.
Thank you.
So I'll take the second bit first, if I may.
James Smith - 1:25:56
Very happy to welcome the committee on the site visit.
And happy to pick that up outside with council officials.
Because I absolutely agree, there's nothing like being
on site to actually understand progress,
but also not just the challenges on site,
but also how we're mitigating those challenges.
Cllr Michael Collins - 1:26:19
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:26:25
Fortunately, that wasn't on the mic, Councillor Collins,
so I've been let off there.
And the first question?
James Smith - 1:26:30
Yeah. And in terms of the first question,
that's not something I'm aware of in terms of cost,
but Phil, is there anything you want to add?
Phil Houghton - 1:26:38
I think the only thing I'd like to mention
to that Councillor Collins is that there are a couple
planning requirements for is in relation to cost that we will pick up at the end
of the project including things like public transport so for instance bus
routes etc so there are there are some requirements on us in that regard so
that will be a dialogue we have between ourselves and the officers I think to
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:27:00
pick up council Collins's point I think what he's highlighting are unintended
costs for parish councils for example and where the traffic into the site
Post and post delivery leads to needing to tidy up road verges littering all that kind of stuff
So I think I think those are the sorts of unintended costs of these things that I think you're flagging. Is that right?
James Smith - 1:27:46
Phil Houghton - 1:27:49
I think what I would say, if it's okay, is that as we get towards the back end of the
project, clearly in terms of the immediate vicinity in and around from our site, then
I think there's conversations that need to be had between officers at the council and
ourselves and our contractor in order to pick up some of those incidentals.
The scope of that I think is just a matter for detail for another day probably.
Oh thank you. I was just going to mention the point about reinstating damage to verges,
because I know that's been a concern of the local parish, and that's something that the MOJ will be required to do,
at a timely point when they're not immediately going to be damaged again.
So the passing bay's have been constructed at the moment.
And that was, you know, we noted damage to verges last week.
So things like that will be rectified at the MOJ's expense.
Jo Thornton - 1:28:41
Thank you.
Councillor Conlon.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:28:44
I think some of my questions have been asked actually.
Cllr Caroline Cornell - 1:28:46
But one of the ones, when we look at these lorry movements,
is that per day or per week on page 22?
The lorry movements in the CTMP are per day, so the peak of 250 is per day.
That's huge, isn't it?
It's a large number of vehicles, yes.
And you won't ever be using farm traffic, will you?
Just keep to your regular contractors.
Farm traffic, did you say?
Well, yes, because I know that when they were doing East West Rail down through Winslow,
they were using farm traffic to get around the regulations of putting lorries through
the town.
Oh, yeah, no, it's road going vehicles will be used
Okay, thank you
Okay. Thank you next I've got cancer field
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:29:29
Cllr Dean Field - 1:29:31
Yeah, it's still morning good morning to you
I'm keeping on the theme. I have many questions, but I'm keeping on the theme about the traffic movement and the lorries the
HGVs
Over this period of time where the construction programme
Stands with all those lorries there is going to be an impact on the road service ie potholes
Can you assure us that any
Addition or any potholes within that area will become under your remit and not Buckinghamshire councils
That's my first question. So my second question either wealth and knowledge regarding this area and
And I believe the Spring Hill development is MOD land owned by MOD the roads within that development.
The services on those roads completely failed many years ago with no upkeep apart from the residents having to put cement into the road themselves.
with all the impact and spring -hilled residents this is going to have on their lives over this construction period.
Can you, as a, or maybe I'll rephrase this, is there a way that we can, or yourselves can resurface those roads to make them a good road service?
the green spaces within that area put over to the residents for ownership
because they don't with all the families on that estate they don't have a park to
play in and I think because they're going to be the the local residents hit
mainly by this development I'll leave my questions at that because I can go on and
on. So thanks very much.
James Smith - 1:31:33
Thank you. So in terms of the first point, I know Phil touched on that earlier, but kind
of reiterate that process we go to to document the state of the roads at the start and regularly
understand the condition of that going forward to make sure that when we have left site from
a construction perspective, noting that we're there for the operation as well for the long
that we make good on that and that's something which we've worked through other new prison sites across the country.
So we'll seek to replicate that process so we can give you assurance on that front.
I understand that there's ongoing dialogue with the residents of the Spring Hill Estate
both in terms of the condition of the roads services but also about the green space.
I'm not going to pretend that it isn't a complicated process because of some of the ownership issues of that end
But again, our previous new prison sites, we've been able to work really
closely with the local community to work through some of those issues.
So I'm not gonna sit here and promise that we'll get to a positive solution.
But what you can have is my assurance that we'll absolutely
engage with residents to see what the artist of possible is.
Because we absolutely recognise that the impact is felt at that hyper local level.
And we also want to make sure that once we conclude this project that there is a lasting legacy for that local community
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:32:57
Thank you, Councillor Drayton
Cllr Penny Drayton - 1:33:00
Thank you chair
Movement I'm going to change something slightly but to one we've very covered but
Residents but off the transport. I'm interested in your report where you've talked about community engagement
And you recognise prisons can be unwelcome developments
You do go on to say that there's a dedicated stakeholder
engagement resource.
You're already holding regular meetings, key stakeholders,
and communicator with residents to provide updates.
Obviously, you were welcomed this morning with an explanation
to us that you had requested this meeting.
I'm presuming we are classed as key stakeholders.
Could you please just give a much clearer image
of what it looks like for what you are doing
with your regular meetings with key stakeholders,
who they are, how regular they are.
And it only says communicating with residents.
Now I would hope that you're meeting with residents.
And again, what that looks like.
When a resident's getting the opportunity to come to meetings,
what is the engagement, how much is being taken on board,
because they are really key stakeholders.
So just if you can explain what that looks like and it's,
there's an unfortunate tendency with large developments
for boxes to be ticked.
And I'm not suggesting that's the case for you.
I'd just like to understand that you're genuinely listening
to residents and giving them an opportunity
because they are the ones on a day -by -day basis
for over 300 weeks which are being affected by this.
Thank you.
James Smith - 1:34:49
And I'll bring in Phil in a bit to go through some
of the details to bring that to life.
But absolutely get where the question's coming from.
And, you know, the communication isn't just simply sending
out a letter every now and again.
It's actual in -face, you know, person to person,
regular engagement with the community at all levels.
and that's something that we've done on other new prison sites.
What we try and do, we have kind of a set process, if you like,
but at the very outset of the project, kind of post -planning,
what we do is we sit down with key stakeholders to say,
well, this is the usual things that we do, but actually, you know,
we want to understand from you how we could tailor this to your needs.
So there's a general way we do it, but each is tailored to individual prison sites.
And in terms of this specific site, I'll hand over to Phil.
Phil Houghton - 1:35:42
Thanks, James.
So a couple of things then.
So first of all, we have a combination
of both monthly and quarterly meetings with parish
and elected member stakeholders.
There's probably around about 9, 10, maybe a dozen
on occasion attendees from that that we meet with.
Naturally, quite a lot of that conversation
relates to the traffic and the questions
that are coming from those parish councillors
and elected members in terms of representing some of the questions
and concerns of their residents.
We've also got a representative of the Spring Hill Estate
that comes to that, attends that as well.
So they're actually participating in that
and raise those sort of comments
that Councillor Field was referring to.
We are arranging a meeting with the residents of Lorne Hill.
We haven't got any date for that as of yet.
We've kind of touched on that over the last couple of weeks
in terms of arranging that, so that will be upcoming.
And we hope to meet with those residents.
I'll refer back to the fact that we've got a, at the moment,
one full -time traffic marshal.
There is an intention to have a second traffic marshal.
The traffic marshal that has been imposed now for,
I want to say, probably about two months,
they have got a good relationship
with the residents of Lawn Hill.
They all know Brian.
They approach Brian, they ask questions to Brian,
So that actually rather than kind of there's email
and there's inbox that James has talked about,
but on a day -to -day basis that there is that interface
on a that they can talk to on a regular basis
to understand questions.
And that's helpful I think because that way
the residents get an answer from a consistent person,
not just whoever they've managed to kind of bump into
up at the site.
I think the other thing I'd say is that for instance
letter drops, I think I'm right in saying that
With our enabling works about to commence,
there's a letter drop that's gone to circa 5 ,000 households
in the community.
So in terms of that, making them aware of what
the impending enabling works and what that looks like.
So in terms of that communication, as I said,
we've got, we talked about the inbox earlier
that for people to write concerns to or ask questions to.
We've got the MOJ HMPPS,
we've got two full -time stakeholder managers who are engaging on that.
And then finally, I'd also kind of reference probably the ongoing engagement we've got
with officers of books, because obviously a lot of the questions and concerns are coming
through that route as well.
So that's another form where we meet with officers at all levels of the Council to talk
about some of those points as well.
So hopefully that's some help.
I can just I wrote it down. It's genuinely it's not box box ticking
We genuinely are engaging we will continue to do that engagement and talk to residents
And we won't be able to always satisfy them
There was a large, you know, very large major project to build but we are listening. We are doing what we can
And that will continue
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:38:53
Yeah
Sure.
Thank you.
Hannah Austin - Service Director for HIF & Major Projects - 1:38:57
I just wanted to add to that that we're always looking at ways in which we can take lessons
from the HS2 project and learn them and apply them to other major infrastructure projects.
There is a well -established Calvert Area Liaison meeting that takes place monthly with local
ward members, parish council members, and others.
And we're looking at whether we can repurpose some of that channel for ongoing conversations
with MOJ and MOJ colleagues as well.
So taking something that's working for another project
that is a good lesson and applying it
to this project as well.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:39:29
Thank you.
Thank you.
Councillor Roberts.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 1:39:32
Thank you.
I came to this quite new at this committee meeting.
So I've been looking at the information
to read myself into the subject.
One of the things I found quite difficult to find
was something that laid out what all of the conditions
and undertakings and commitments actually are.
There doesn't seem to be a schedule or something laying all of that out in an easily accessible
form.
Not that I found anyway.
Maybe you could point me in the right direction if I've not found it.
But I think that would be something that would be quite helpful to see all of the commitments
and then against each of those, how they're being monitored and what the enforcement route
is against each of those.
What I'm particularly interested in, and it relates to the highways issues, the traffic
issues, is about which of those elements are proactively managed to be achieved and which
are more sort of passively dealt with as report,
reports of noncompliance are raised.
Jo Thornton - 1:40:52
I was just going to come to your second point, first,
Councillor Roberts.
And that is in reference to the compliance,
because as you've heard already this morning, the MOJ submits
monthly monitoring figures.
and they're very detailed, which is very helpfully shared
with officers in the council.
We then review them to ensure compliance.
So that's a second cheque.
And then there's the escalation process if we need to do that,
both internally and with our partners at the MOJ as well.
To your point about where is everything set out,
I find that quite interesting to hear and understand.
I mean, the CTMP is available on the planning portal,
But appreciate, you know, that's, there are many,
many hundreds of documents that are indeed in that location.
So I think that's probably something for us to take away
and make sure you've got access to those easily.
If I can just clarify, it's not just the CTM, CMTP.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 1:41:50
It's about all of the other wider undertakings.
There's.
Planning obligations.
Planning obligations.
The commitments have been made about employment
and apprenticeships and so on, they're not all in one place as far as I can tell.
So it makes it difficult to see what they all are.
Claire Bayley - 1:42:15
So in terms of the planning conditions attached to the consent itself, they are all set out
within the planning appeal decision.
And the way the inspector has set them out is they're sort of batched and grouped into themes.
So there's ecology -related conditions, there's highway -related conditions.
So they are set out within one document.
It is an extensive list of conditions and each of those conditions will be processed as they come into the system,
either in a batch of an application that covers multiple conditions or individual condition applications,
which then all individually get recorded.
So I can appreciate that, you know, for a project of this scale, it maybe is quite challenging.
Perhaps if the intention is that we're to return back to GIH select committee for a
future meeting, that perhaps we could create a sort of summary schedule of those conditions
and where we at with those.
In terms of Section 106 obligations, that would be monitored through our still in Section
106 team.
And so, so overarchingly, we would be sort of monitoring.
And I think to your point of if there isn't compliance, then I think, well, initially
there would be a conversation between officers and the MOJ directly to see if we can resolve
that.
Ultimately, if matters can't be resolved, then there are steps that we can take depending
on the nature of the breach of those obligations.
But I think it is about proportionality at that point.
But as we say, there's been really positive engagement between the MOJ and the Council,
and certainly an aspiration to work towards ensuring that compliance is maintained.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 1:43:55
Thank you. I think that would be helpful if there was, I don't know, some sort of schedule
that laid them all out with, sort of pointed off to where they can be found. I think that
would be like an index to them. I think that would be a helpful thing.
The other point I wanted to explore was building on something that Councillor Moore raised,
which was about the monitoring of the HGV movements.
My own experience in Amersham is I've had years now
of dealing with HGV movements from HS2
and monitoring of off -road, off -route traffic, et cetera,
and complaints about non -compliance
and dealing with all of those.
I think the point that I'd pick up
that I'm not sure was answered with Councillor Moore's was,
if I'm a member of the public,
how do I know where to go to raise complaints
and how would I go about logging something
that I've got a concern about?
I think that is, from my experience,
that is something that come to me
and I end up being a letterbox of passing on complaints.
I've actually got a number of people around my area
who send me dash cam videos of HGVs that are off route.
And oh, is this an HS2 one or not?
And I think if we can have some sort of mechanism that makes
that easier that the public are aware of and can be used,
I think that would be a really helpful mechanism.
And I didn't, to be honest, I didn't hear you say
that in response to Councillor Moore's question.
James Smith - 1:45:45
Thank you. So let me make it clear now then that's a helpful point. So in all of our communications,
we always include our dedicated mailbox, which is essentially that single point of focus
for any questions, concerns, complaints. All of the emails we get are logged and are actioned
accordingly. So that is the single source, if you like, for residents. What I was trying
to allude to is, you know, some people prefer different methods as well, you know, and we've
got things in place where, you know, be it traffic ambassadors, marshals, where particularly
if it's local residents, they can also use that forum if they don't want to go through
the email inbox.
But that is the main place.
It was on the, again, it was on the most recent letter that came out from me or is coming
out from me in terms of updating residents in that circa 5000 kind of mail drop area.
Again to let them know where they can send inquiries. And that's also on the report that
was shared with the committee too.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 1:46:49
And finally if I may, the programme's going on a long time and there'll be various stages
within that. I assume when you get further down the line there's more to bringing on
online a new prison than just building it.
So I have some professional experience
of the recruitment side of prison officer recruitment,
and the pipeline there is a lengthy process.
I assume that you'll be in your updates to stakeholders,
that you'll be including more of a strategic trajectory
of what the stages are that are upcoming
and when different elements might be kicking in over the lifetime of the programme.
To put it simply, yes, that is correct.
James Smith - 1:47:36
Yes, that's what we'll seek today.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:47:37
Thank you.
Last contribution before I wrap up with a couple of final ones.
Councillor Waters.
Thank you.
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 1:47:45
I think we've raised quite a lot of issues here.
There are a couple of points and going back on that, all these LORRI movements and you're
tracking them to the site, but most defences take place
from HS2 when they leave and they take a different route
because they've got a job going somewhere
completely differently.
And that is the bit which has to be monitored
because that's when things, the control disappears.
I presume you're controlling the arrival
and leaving from the site under that process.
And because you've got this sort of setup
where with HS2 they put something in the window so everyone could see if they're in HS2 or not.
Obviously other things go on, you might finish up getting blamed for things which have nothing to do with you.
That actually is a useful thing if you're looking at people who are going to complain
and you'll probably reduce that if that's in the window.
But that's one thing.
Second thing is obviously you've committed to ensuring that the roads are kept to a reasonable standard.
The areas where there was significant issues and are around Amersham or any of the routes that I know of,
anywhere near roundabouts and junctions because of the sheer weight of the vehicles,
Almost all of those have had to be repaired, either with HS2 paying or us doing it ourselves
because of the sheer pressure that goes on the roads.
And that are quite a long way away from the sites.
So just want to make sure we're not doing something that is just too localised.
If that's on the route, those areas need to be looked at because they're the bits that
break down first.
And hopefully we have got the information on those.
and that the timely repair, that we're not having to go begging
to another government organisation or semi -government organisation for money
over years eventually comes through, that hopefully we get a timely response
on making sure the roads are up to standard.
And the third point is where you're doing these dialogues, constant dialogues,
Is there actually some ability where you can put some funding into something?
Obviously you've got your marshals, but are there other things within the local community
where you have funding where you can say actually for the long term here there may be some extra
measures that will need to be going in or going in now that would help, you know, whether
that's speed bumps or various issues, things that you can do to calm traffic or things
like that through the villages.
So there's a mix of different things.
It's just to try and make sure we've really nailed those things
down really firmly for the local committee.
Just to speak quite clear, I'm one of the,
I think maybe the only one who was on the committee
that turned this down and was really unhappy with it.
So actually protect the residents as much
as we can is something I feel responsible for here.
Thank you.
James Smith - 1:50:51
I think there's three key points, questions there.
So I'm going to invite Adrian to cover the first question.
Phil will come in on the second, and then I'll come in on the third
in terms of that wider benefit and value to the community.
Adrian Stearn - 1:51:04
With regards to the control of vehicles when leaving the site,
that's a really good point.
And someone mentioned before about transfer of knowledge.
And so we've recently engaged a logistics manager that's
been involved in this region.
He's also a local.
He lives in Bisto, and he plays for Bisto Rugby Club and things.
So he's very much part of this community and has friends and colleagues in the villages that are around this this new development
so he's certainly taking this very personally and very engaged and making sure we deliver it the right way as we all are and
for the
The moment at the moment the vast majority of the vehicles that come and go from the project of Earth
Oh girth works and they are transporting the materials from the project sites
around via the A41 and into the FCC Calvert reclamation site.
So it's very much a point -to -point loop, backwards and forwards,
circulatory route at the moment.
And then we have imports of granular materials from stone,
which is also from the same point quarry.
So it's very much a backwards and forwards route.
I think your point will be very valid as we move into the main works
and then we get a much more diverse set of vehicles coming to the project.
And at that point, it's about reliance on the telemetry,
that the suppliers have in their vehicles.
So when we start to engage the suppliers
that will make deliveries for other items that will come
from manufacturing places around the country by necessity,
then we'll be leaning into them and the telemetry that they have
on their vehicles so that we can monitor via them the compliance
to the routes.
But at the moment as well, while we don't have that facility,
we also do spot cheques on monitoring
and following the vehicles to make sure
that the microwave vehicles are going
to where we think they're going,
and also checking that they are following
the prescribed routes in the CTMP.
Thanks, Adrian.
In terms of the second question,
Phil Houghton - 1:53:01
and the scope and the remit of repairs to the road network,
it's always on all of these projects,
it's always quite a tricky topic,
because naturally we've got all of our traffic,
and we've talked earlier about the kind of daily numbers,
which we said it's a large number.
There's no getting away from that point.
We know that obviously there's extensive HS2 traffic
and for some time yet, and of course,
there's all of the other traffic that is above
and beyond that and nothing to do
with either of those projects.
So we understand our responsibilities.
We understand that we are a party to that.
The detail of how far that goes and the scope of that,
I think we've all got to get into those conversations.
because on the one hand we're not going to shy away from our responsibilities
but on the other hand obviously there's a balance to that in terms of where our
responsibilities start and end. We've started, we have had some of those
discussions with HS2 colleagues already around the principle they haven't gone
very far yet. It's more about just keep chipping away and talking about it.
Those conversations need to continue and equally we obviously need to pick up
those conversations with officers from books as well.
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 1:54:16
Yeah, it's that sort of balance which is concerning me
because as soon as you're linking with HS2,
that's not necessarily a good history
that we're going through there,
particularly anyone who's trying to keep our highways
in a reasonable condition.
So I think we definitely would want some clarification
that that doesn't slip and residents locally
not putting up with massive potholes that we have in inability to deal with because
of the cash flow that we have.
James Smith - 1:54:50
And I think, you know, as Phil's reflected, there are still some things we need to work
through on that front, both with wider organisations, HS2 and with council officials.
But hopefully what you've seen today is our visible demonstration of a commitment to engage
and have those conversations.
So absolutely reiterate that.
Just on the third point in terms of the wider benefit and value to the local community.
That's definitely a conversation we want to get into.
Appreciate it's still quite early days on the project so far, but as again, as we've
seen from other delivering new prisons in other parts of the country, what we've been
able to do is through working closely with our construction partners is deliver what
we refer to as wider social value on the project.
And that's not just about the job creation
and the spend locally.
That is also through funding,
what I would refer to as sometimes small things
in the grand scheme of the financial amount
but have a real significant impact locally.
So for example, at one of our most recent prisons
up at York, not just things like volunteering
and fundraising for local community initiatives
that the construction team and the project team will get involved in, but also things
like fixing roofs on the local swimming pool and that sort of thing.
So there is a process of which we collect ideas from the community about initiatives
that we could look at and consider and we'll absolutely seek to replicate that.
We're not quite there yet and we won't be for a little bit of time, but it's something
that's definitely on our radar to do and will hopefully mean we can talk about something
else apart from traffic management.
Yeah, probably you particularly know some of Councillor Fields'
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 1:56:40
items.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 1:56:43
OK, thank you.
Just a couple of final things from me.
So I think one of the key themes emerging from this
is about being good neighbours.
And I think part of the, and obviously there's
a lot of discussion about traffic,
and that does need to be investigated.
And I think HS2 unfortunately has left a real scar
for the community across Buckinghamshire that you are
coming off the back of and therefore the expectation is clearly higher.
But I think being a good neighbour goes beyond just the construction journey.
And I just want to explore a bit of the longer term legacy if I can.
So I would say that one of the things not to make the mistake of with HS2
is to think that funding playgrounds, volunteering is a way to deal with the
consequences of what is quite a major infrastructure change that people don't want.
And I think I just who made that mistake
Thinking that just by funding these things here and there people would kind of be happy with all the disruption
It needs to sit alongside some bigger things
And so I think one of the things that's not clear to me is that the metrics that you're using in the examples that you?
give of mil psych
Wells etc when you look at the radius that you're applying
To the benefits the job creation. It's quite a big radius 50 miles
which if you look at where this prison is takes us into Oxford, takes us into
beyond Bicester and so just we get to understand a little bit about how do you
genuinely see those benefits really impacting the near -term communities of
Spring Hill, Grendan etc rather than the benefits being felt by the Oxford's the
Bisters and it leads a little bit to the second point which as I understand it
This is likely to be a private sector run prison.
I don't think unless I've not found it
that you've appointed who is going to actually run
the prison yet.
And they are the legacy partner.
And it'd be good just to understand
how will you translate the commitments that you're making
into the longer term role that they have
as a community and a neighbour.
Because they are the people that are
going to cause the issues for the parish councils
and for residents, not necessarily you
when you're gone with the construction element.
And I think that, again, leads into the question
about the radius impact.
Because I should declare that I previously
led one of the big education and training providers
in the prison system.
And the reality is that you can do as much education
and training as you want in the prison sector
if the jobs and employment opportunities
in the surrounding area aren't there to resettle prisoners
into with those skills later.
It's all pretty pointless.
It's understanding again with the large radius that you're setting out and you're saying that people these prisoners will from the resettlement
That will settle into the local communities. How have you thought about the Buckinghamshire?
economic plan and
What we're looking to do in Buckinghamshire to help drive the requirements into the prison system for any provider around education employment
Just take us through what engagement you've had with the council around the role
You see this prison playing in our delivery of our economic plan to just gain give us confidence that
This isn't just going to be a piece of infrastructure landed dropped and isn't going to add long -term benefit to the county
James Smith - 2:00:06
Thank you
so in terms of the
the point about
Benefits and the kind of some of the metrics that we use so I think it's a fair challenge
You'll also appreciate where we're holding a couple of things here in terms of
We need to to set that that target when we have
But it was also got a balance the fact that it's got to be achievable and also ensure that we can still deliver the project
Because some of the supply chain and components naturally just sit outside of a certain radius
So again, we're early stages of the project yet
So one of the things that I'll be looking at closely when the data starts to come in in terms of that
50 mile radius is to dig beneath that a bit more and actually see you know
what are the ranges that we're in on that?
Is it mostly 40 to 50 miles,
or what proportion is much more local than that?
And that's something which I'll happily work through
in a further discussion.
So a kind of challenge accepted on that point.
I would also say and refer to the previous conversation
about those are some high level metrics,
but also the ambition is there for that wider social value,
which Sarah, the stakeholder manager in my team,
refers to as hyperlocal, that's her phrase for this.
So that is the immediate benefits for the community.
So that ambition, that aim is absolutely there on that front.
In terms of the operation point,
you're correct as the report says,
we anticipate that it will be a privately operated prison,
but that's subject to a separate business case process,
ministerial decision,
which will happen further down the line.
Regardless of whether this prison is publicly or privately operated,
absolutely we will want to ensure that those commitments to be a good neighbour
is not just a construction thing.
So there'll be a handover piece from the constructor to the operator, whoever that is,
and that will also hand over some of the obligations on a practical,
but also a more engagement level as well.
If it was to be privately operated, one of the things that we do in the competitive procurement process is also test that kind of
their plans for that engagement locally both through the mobilisation period which is before the prison opens
right the way through ramp up and in life delivery, but we absolutely recognise the point you make in terms of you know
Yes, everyone's focused on the traffic and the construction quite rightly
so completely understand that, but we're also looking at the longer term piece.
My responsibility as SRO is that full life of the project.
So it's not just about delivering a building.
So hopefully that reassurance there.
On the economic plan and engagement, again, I think that's something that
we need to discuss further with officials to make sure that as our plans progress,
we're aligning with that.
And I think we're starting those conversations and we'll need to continue that.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:03:06
Great, thank you.
It's been a really helpful discussion.
Thank you so much for your time.
And I think it would be good as we progress through the journey for you to come back and
us just play that.
I think actually if at that stage we could also look to perhaps invite the parish council
to come and share their perspectives through that journey as well.
I think that would be a really good thing to do.
But I appreciate your time today and thank you very much.
We will take a five minute break and reconvene.
So can I ask everyone to be here at 10 past 12.
Thank you.

7 Housing Allocation Policy Report

Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:03:37
Great.
So we're moving on to item number seven, which is the housing allocation policy report.
So we're going to review the operation of the housing allocation policy, which was reviewed during 2024.
So last year was the first full year operational year of the revised policy.
I'll just ask you to introduce yourselves for the public and then we'll get into it.
Thank you Chairman. Councillor Gary Hall, Deputy Cabinet Member for Housing and Regulatory Services.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 2:04:16
Sorry Chairman. Steve Bambrick, Corporate Director of Planning, Growth and Sustainability.
Chairman, John Holman, Interim Director of Housing and Strategy.
Hi, I'm Tom Chettle, I'm the Head of Housing.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:04:32
Hi, I'm Rachel M. Stavis, I'm the Housing Options Manager.
Great, thank you. Who's to kick us off? Gary.
Cllr Gary Hall - 2:04:44
Thank you, Chairman. I'm pleased to introduce this report on the performance of Bucks Home Choice following the implementation of the revised housing allocations policy in March 2025.
Members will be aware that Buckinghamshire, like many areas of the country, continues to face significant pressures in relation to affordable housing.
Demand for social housing remains far greater than the number of homes available, and it is therefore essential that the Council has a fair, transparent and robust allocation scheme that prioritises those households in the greatest need.
The policy was reviewed and updated in response to those pressures.
The changes were designed to ensure that limited social housing resources are targeted more effectively,
strengthen local connexion requirements, create a single county -wide scheme,
and provide greater priority to households facing the most acute housing challenges.
The report provides an overview of the first full year of operation under the revised policy,
the findings are encouraging.
The re -registration exercise and policy changes
have resulted in a more accurate
and actively managed housing register
whilst continuing to reflect the significant demand
for affordable housing across Buckinghamshire.
The report also demonstrates that allocations
are being directed towards those households
with the highest levels of need,
including homeless households
and families experiencing overcrowding and that the county -wide approach is
helping us make the best possible use of the limited social housing stock
available. It is important to recognise that no allocations policy can on its
own solve the challenge of a shortage of affordable homes. However what this
report demonstrates is that the council has put in place a strong framework that
helping ensure available homes are allocated fairly, consistently and to those who need
the most. I would like to thank officers and our registered
provider partners for their work in implementing these changes and I welcome the committee's
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:06:56
comments and questions. Thank you.
Cllr David Moore - 2:07:01
Councillor Moore. Thank you, Chairman. Thank you for your report
And it's very welcome to see the emphasis on the local connexion going up to five years
from two.
Where I represent in the south of the county, I'm sure many of my colleague members would
agree with me, we represent wards and we represent residents living in very high income slash
high asset value areas, where houses are very expensive.
And I want to know specifically what is going to do to address the backlog we have.
and this changed the allocations.
How will this improve housing, especially in the south
where there is a squeeze on housing
when we're seeing certain housing stock being taken
and used for temporary accommodation by other councils,
such as Ealing Council runs housing stock in my ward,
and of course, Verdon Court, Sloughborough Council,
starting to use some of the units as well,
but there's still lots of units available.
So, what are we going to do to use these existing units and ensure that our residents, especially
in the south as well as across the county, are housed instead of letting other councils
essentially just use our housing stock?
Thank you.
Thank you.
Councillor Moore, I'll attempt to answer some of that.
And I think there's two separate areas which I think you've touched on.
Our report is obviously in relation to affordable homes,
and we're doing some work in relation to the pipeline
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:08:36
of affordable homes across books.
And may have touched on it earlier in relation
to the local plan and some of those discussions.
And the other area of work is in relation
to temporary emergency accommodations,
such as Verdon Court and some of the operation
which you've referenced, Ealing Council.
We're doing a lot of work
with what we would call nightly pay providers,
that providers of, private providers
of emergency accommodation.
We have a framework within Buckinghamshire
that which those providers join or already on.
And we're using what we need.
I think that there is always a risk
that we don't necessarily need all
of the emergency accommodation which is in the market.
We're trying to access those which are most cost effective
and most available for us.
I think the second question is, is when we,
particularly around emergency accommodation.
If we have a family coming into emergency accommodation
who may have strong links to the South of Book,
there might be school connexions,
there might be critical, they might be getting their care
in Wexham Park Hospital, we'll always attempt to look
at the nearest possible emergency accommodation
to those critical needs for that family or that household.
Thank you.
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 2:09:48
Councillor Stutchbury.
Yeah, thank you for the report.
I also thank you for finally publishing the Anthony Collins legal models for delivering
houses only took from 2020 so we're really pleased to see that document published now.
What I'd like to ask you and it's clearly you got confidence in this
policy to deliver the houses because I really haven't and I also want to know how you can
managed situations which you've got now where Casilio,
which is one of the housing providers
which provides accommodation,
is in difficulty financially,
and I believe in their business model
was to deliver key worker houses,
and that will have a negative effect,
that uncertainty on us being able to house
some of the most vulnerable people.
So I want to know how that,
you're understanding that in your modelling,
because your policy doesn't state that.
It presumes everyone's going to stay in place.
That isn't going to be the case.
And I do fear there's no figures in here
but demonstrate how the changes in the delivery model
has delivered more houses,
accommodation for local residents,
both in South Buckinghamshire, as Councillor Moore pointed out,
and in North Buckinghamshire,
because we should be looking to how is our own.
There used to be a suballocation policy in the district which was abolished by this authority
which aimed to do that.
And there's been no comparable subsequent decision.
That suballocation policy was meant to those properties that receive development, receive
social housing for their target.
That's gone.
But the policy now, the way the figures have changed, may have reduced the amount of people
on the housing register, but has it really truly reduced the need to be on the register?
And I don't see any figures in this report.
Nothing would give me confidence.
And going back to the Casilio question, those type of matters really can be a determinant
factor on you being able to get outside providers to provide the very people we all care for
around here to be housed.
and I see vulnerabilities in this through and through and through and I don't think
you'll be surprised I say that because I've said it for a very long time. Thank you.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:12:24
Who will state that? Steve.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 2:12:27
Chair, can I just clarify the very first question I think Councillor Stutchbury was asking was
you asked about do we have confidence in the policy to deliver houses. Were you referring
there to the local plan policy or another policy? Let me elaborate for you.
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 2:12:46
Don't elaborate just clarify. When I say your policy the policy we're considering
here is the policy in this report not your policy in that. If you want to talk
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 2:13:00
about that I will do but I don't think you want me to thank you. Okay well so
just on this particular policy the allocations policy this policy is
specifically about how we make decisions of
to connect people to
The houses that are available. It's not designed in and of itself to be a policy for
Increasing the supply of housing there are other policies. Of course local plan is one of those
That will look towards the actual supply of housing and there'll be other mechanisms as well, which you've alluded to
such as working directly with the registered providers in Buckinghamshire as well and some of their and their own development
programmes to actually increase the supply so and I won't comment specifically on those given that we're talking
Just about the allocations policy today. You also referenced in your question
concilio as one of the potential vehicles and
for
delivering in your reference key worker housing just for clarification.
So Consilio is a company that's owned by the council.
It was a company that was established before the council was became unitary.
It was established by the former South books District Council.
It actually only holds I understand I think two housing developments and
It also holds some commercial developments as well.
I think the sustainability of concilios
a going concern is something I know
that the council is looking at
because it doesn't I think have a very significant long -term
future. It was a it was a programme that was inherited
from by this Council from from South Box Council
and it's not something that we're looking at in terms
of a long -term vehicle for holding or delivering new new
housing stock. I think the key to delivering and holding housing stock is the strategic
development and strategic partnership that the council has and will continue to have
with the registered providers that operate across the county area. Those will be the
people that will drive forward the delivery and of course they will be working directly
with those of the developers who will be delivering on the local plan targets
that we that we've referenced today as well. I don't know if Tom wants to pick up
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:15:31
any more detail. Thank you Councillor Stutchbury. I was just going to add I
think the latter part of your question was the register may have
the review of a policy may have reduced the register but has it reduced the need
and I think clearly not there's you know nationally as well as in Buckingham
year. We're managing lots of homeless households approaching the council needing support. The
register and affordable housing is one mechanism to support that need. There are other mechanisms
such as working with private landlords and seeking private rental properties and so on
to support some of that need as well.
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 2:16:14
Just to follow up briefly, you did say that the council,
did the council have some financial exposure to Concilio,
or was it a silent partner,
because it's quite a consideration
that we need to understand,
because you may say it only had two developments
or two sets of houses,
but in South Buckinghamshire,
two of anything for social housing is very, very,
very large considering so little development
takes place of this nature in South Bucklewshire. So I think that needs some clarity. If it
isn't, if it's financially sensitive, say it's financially sensitive, but I think they
need some clarity around that.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 2:16:58
The clarity I can give is that Consilio is own, it's wholly owned by the council. So
the council is financially linked to Consilio and there'll be decisions for the council
to make in terms of conciliar which are not before this committee today.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:17:12
Thank you.
Councillor Collins.
Cllr Michael Collins - 2:17:14
Thank you, Chairman.
Page 43 of the report, households in substantive temporary accommodation.
The outcome and target figure 55 % against a target of 60 has that to relate to the number
of households.
The second question to that is, when we talk about moving households or service, the average
nightly cost is £79.
Is that per household or per individual?
If it's £79 per household, what do they get for their money?
Thank you, Councillor Collins.
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:17:56
I think you were referencing the performance report, I think,
rather than the allocation policy.
I'm happy to answer those.
I think there's two questions, and I think that was the
question in relation to substantive temporary
accommodation, and so within the report you'll see
that we've got a target of people, households residing
in emergency temporary accommodation,
60 % of those residing in substantive.
And substantive temporary accommodation is run
by a registered housing provider or run directly by the council.
And we've been doing lots of work in relation
to emergency accommodation.
So we've been doing regular reviews of people who have been
in temporary accommodation for the longest to support faster
move -on plans and to move them on out of temporary accommodation.
And we've also been doing a great deal of work with looking
at our own in -house temporary accommodation in terms
of the provider who supports us with our VOIDs work
and improving the turnaround so that we can really maximise use
of our substantive units.
And the.
Cllr Michael Collins - 2:19:07
Sorry, 55 % against a total of 60%.
Are we talking numbers of households rather
than just percentages?
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:19:20
I'm not sure I can answer that directly now
because I'm not absolutely sure on the numbers
of the households which we've got in substantive
when this report was done,
but it might be something which I can come back
with the absolute detail, sorry.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:19:38
Okay, if you can come back to us on that.
Can we just remind members to put your mic on
so we can pick you up in the thing.
And then next bit, yeah.
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:19:46
I didn't know if there was a latter part of the question
which was just clarity about the nightly paid rates,
and that was per household rather than per person.
So that's the rate which the council pays for emergency,
temporary accommodation to the private sector.
And that's to obviously support households
in having what they require for emergency accommodations,
so such as, you know, kitchen facilities,
bathroom facilities, a self -contained unit
to support them.
Cllr Michael Collins - 2:20:14
Last point, if I may, is that the number of members of the family within that particular
household, number of people, somebody relevant, so 79 pounds, whether it's a single person
or a family of two parents and two children, it's 79 pounds.
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:20:34
It's an average.
So there'll be single households where the average cost, you know, where the main average
cost maybe 50 pounds per night or under,
whereas for larger households with six -plus people,
that nightly rate might be over 150 pounds per night.
So the average is within the report.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:20:52
Thank you.
Councillor Nella.
Cllr Frances Kneller - 2:20:55
Thank you, Chair.
I've got one point of clarification
and two questions.
On the data sheets on Appendix 1, the average waiting times
for Band A based on households housed in March 2026 is exactly the same as the
figures for households housed in 2025. Has somebody put the same report in twice
rather than because I'm surprised it to the last number it's exactly the same. So
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:21:43
Cllr Frances Kneller - 2:21:52
which is required for some I won't highlight.
Again, looking at the data information,
we've had no four or five bedroom properties to let.
And that's been consistent.
We also need six bedroom units.
And I'm really concerned about how and what
we're actively doing to actually deliver those homes
and deliver them speedily,
because we've got a large number of families
across Buckinghamshire who are desperate for the large units
and are restricted from moving to larger homes
because the policy says you've got to have the size
that you need, not the size that you've got.
So can I ask how and how quickly you're going to be able
to bring some larger homes online?
And my other point is to do with the allocations.
We do have families who are placed from outside the area
by other local authorities,
sometimes into private accommodation and for any household, any person relocating
a long distance outside the areas that they're used to is difficult and takes
time to assimilate. Some of those families if they're in private
rented because that's what happens could end up staying in Buckinghamshire for
quite a long time but there doesn't seem to be any way where those families could
actually come on to the list because once you're here you've got
your children in school, you've got jobs, you want to become part of the community
So, I was looking to find somewhere how we would enable families who are of long -standing,
long status in Buckinghamshire, albeit placed there by another council, have the opportunity
to actually come onto the list.
Because no doubt, once you've put roots down, you want to stay and not necessarily go back
to where you came from.
Thank you.
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:23:54
Thank you, Councillor Keller, and we'll try and answer your questions across us.
I think one in relation to larger homes, particularly four, five, even six bedrooms homes,
it is a really challenging area for us.
We are at the moment what we're getting some success on is particularly looking at the private sector
with private landlords looking at those larger units around the county.
And we have got a pipeline of those coming online and we've had success with supporting the larger households.
Did you want to come back?
Cllr Frances Kneller - 2:24:28
I'd like to come back on that because why would somebody want to move out of a social affordable homes into the private sector?
To be honest. I'm looking very much at people who are needing to transfer
I can understand if you're coming onto the list and that may be the only option to get the right size
But people who are on our list are people who are looking to transfer and have come on and need to move on
And if we've got nothing again if the local
registered providers are not building anything either.
We need to look long and hard
because at least they could do internal transfers to help.
But for families who need
that larger accommodation is really a concern that we need
to be thinking about because of the damage and difficulties
that it creates for families in very overcrowded homes.
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:25:16
So I think there's a couple of sides to it.
So one in relation to affordable homes and the pipeline.
So we're doing a lot of work with our registered providers
to understand there is a pipeline.
And there is a pipeline of four -bedroom homes
which do come through, and they do go onto the register.
And we obviously have some success with placing,
there's obviously moves from three bedrooms to four bedrooms
or two bedrooms to four bedrooms and so on.
I think the other side of it as well is some
of the older housing stock often has a larger sort of dining room
or a larger room downstairs.
And we've worked really hard with some
our registered housing providers to see if that meets the minimum bedroom standards and
to support.
So the free bedroom with the large dining room, you know, can that be used?
So we've absolutely tried to maximise those homes.
I think the second part in relation to private rentals, absolutely, there's a lot, you know,
maybe not seen as, I can't exactly remember your exact wording, but the Renters' Rights
Act has provided a lot of new a lot of new assurances for tenants moving into private
rentals a lot more security and we've seen you know that that's had some positive response
across the people we're working with when particularly when looking for larger larger
units larger homes to support people out of emergency temporary accommodation.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:26:39
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 2:26:43
Cllr Frances Kneller - 2:26:46
Thank you. I have Councillor Waters next. There was a further point that I think they
were going to ask regarding families who were relocated here. Thank you. Yeah I'll
Rachel Emms-Davies - Housing Options Manager - 2:26:54
pick up on that point. So if families are being placed into Buckinghamshire and
it's temporary accommodation arrangements with other local
authorities, the time spent in that temporary accommodation in Buckinghamshire
wouldn't count towards a local connexion on Bucks Home Choice. If
they're placed and it's a private rental and that's discharging that councils
homeless duties towards them then it would count towards that starting their
five -year local connexion so if they're placed in temporary accommodation by
another local authority they may still be able to access the housing register
but with a lower band than people who are already living in Buckinghamshire
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:27:29
John Holman - Interim Service Director for Housing - 2:27:31
and have got that close local connexion thank you and John thank you can I just
pick up on the local, the pipeline issues.
So we've got the immediate challenges that Tom spoke
about where we're trying to find the larger properties.
More strategically, we're looking ahead with the RPs
to try to understand for the local plan
where the accommodation will be.
But if we get upstream, work with the RPs,
try to influence them and shape what, when and where,
we then link that with what our projections are
for homelessness in terms of families sizes.
And then we can see what the gap is between supply and demand.
So that's the piece of strategic work
that is going on at the moment in the other parts of housing.
And then we're looking at what other levers we can pull.
Because doing the same thing won't close that gap.
So looking at other options that we can bring before you.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:28:25
Cllr Jonathan Waters - 2:28:26
Council Waters.
Yes, in terms of the work that was done behind this, the logic was there because we had all
the various authorities having completely their own rules and there were different needs
across Buckinghamshire. And so actually pulling this together, particularly I know in my own
patch in the south where there was very limited social housing, it did give people who had
very significant needs where they were applying in the Aylesbury area, their needs were put
down really, really low until we actually brought this together rather than actually
now they're looked at the right level, the right banding across the whole area.
So those with the most needs are getting the priorities.
What we've also done is obviously we've cleaned up what's there, but what it's come out with
is a baseline, a very strong baseline that doesn't look like it's going to be shifting anytime soon.
And with that, the 5000 plus waiting list is looking pretty stubborn and that doesn't seem to be.
And that's where we're looking at probably where the local plan, so probably Steve Brownback to answer,
So if we were looking at the local plan, how is that going to feed in to actually start
bringing the 5 ,000 down?
What do you see that as?
Because what's set in the local plan is well below the overall need when we looked at need
within it.
So but what level do you think this will start driving those numbers down?
because if we keep delivering 245, 312 houses year on year,
that sort of level, other than the throughput,
we're not going to get anywhere.
The larger houses as well are important.
And I was actually a bit worried because I
had one very large house in my ward, which was taken up,
where the council placed a traveller family there
who set up business.
And a whole range of things went on.
and they will move very, very quickly.
So it's not always the, I think you need to be in control
of where you're placing people
who have significant wider needs
without causing absolute mayhem in a community.
So those large houses, I see what was done,
but that wasn't necessarily the correct
or the right location without the rules
because there was a whole number of other people
started living at the house.
So that's an extra item.
But if we could actually look at those numbers
and how we're going to drive that 5 ,000 down from it, that would be good.
But I think that some of the local plans can have to do that.
Steve Bambrick - Corporate Director for Planning, Growth & Sustainability - 2:31:14
Yeah, if I may, without getting into a debate about the local plan again, Chair,
I think what I would say just on the local plan,
and I think this was a question that was asked at Cabinet,
actually when the Cabinet were also considering it,
is there are targets for delivering affordable homes within the local plan
and those targets are set based on the viability evidence principally that supports the local plan.
Now, of course that will be tested through the examination.
So as I say I won't get into the nuances of that.
But other than to say what that viability shows us is that we are looking to maximise the delivery of affordable housing.
Now of course we're maximising that knowing that we have a very significant level of need
and the housing need assessment is also part of the local plan evidence base.
But we also know that we are required to deliver very, very high overall housing numbers in Buckinghamshire.
So the proportion of affordable housing whilst of course we would all like it to be bigger in order to meet that affordable housing need.
It is still a big number because we've been delivering an overall big number as well across the across the county and
Again, I just refer you to the point that John made
in answer to council and Ella's question, which is with that as context in terms of what we're delivering across the
across the county the strategic housing
responsibility is to then get ahead of the curve and know what's coming from a local development perspective and
Work directly with developers, work directly with the registered providers to make sure that when we are providing the affordable housing on those sites.
It is directly meeting the needs that we know exist in those areas.
And that's in terms of the type and size of accommodation.
And that's part of the strategic housing function that we are working directly with registered providers on.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:33:13
Thank you. Councillor Roberts.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 2:33:17
I am going to go tackle this point as well.
I mean, what we're hearing in this is there's simply not enough homes coming on stream to
help meet the needs and to house the people who are on the list.
And we can see in the wait times, some of these wait times are really quite disturbing.
you know, four years as the longest wait. And it's basically down to there being not
enough supply of homes. Now, as far as the local plan is concerned,
it's baked into the local plan that it's not going to deliver sufficient affordable homes.
Now, you talked about working with registered providers, but the registered providers aren't
going to be able to deliver enough homes either because there aren't going to be the sites
for them to develop on. That's what it says in the local plan. There aren't going to be
sufficient sites to meet the need. So my concern is what is that going to do with these wait
times and the number of people who are on the list? Looking forward, what's the prospects
for the future length of the lists and the wait times that people will be experiencing
in future based on what we know is laid out in the local plan for the supply of affordable
housing which is the driver of a lot of this need for housing.
I understand why you've done it.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:34:47
If I may just stay focused on the housing allocation rather than the local plan component
you'll have your chance next week.
That's correct.
Yeah, that's fine.
That's how we did it.
My question is around what does this do for the housing
Cllr Mark Roberts - 2:34:59
allocation and the wait line.
I just don't want to get into a local plan discussion.
I'll respond, Chair.
John Holman - Interim Service Director for Housing - 2:35:05
Although given, trying to predict an answer to that,
I think at this point it's almost impossible to at least
kind of look at the numbers in terms of what a projection
of homeless are and what are the pipeline that comes through.
What this policy clearly does, though,
is make sure what resources we have got,
those scarce resources, are fairly allocated
across the county.
We should also recognise, I think,
there's probably over a thousand applicants on the register
that are in very low priority.
They've accommodated without any problem at all,
but they've registered on that list for a home
at some point in the future.
So in terms of answering the question,
I simply can't.
It's a national problem that everybody's trying to work with,
but until we understand what that pipeline looks like,
what our projections are in terms of numbers of units,
types of families, are they two, three, four, five bed units,
and how we can influence that, it's going to be very difficult.
I think as we start to look through the numbers,
we can start to give better projections,
but at the moment sitting here, I can't.
And going right back to the beginning of one of the questions,
I have confidence in what I see in front of me as a policy in terms of making equitable
allocations for those people that need them across the county.
If I may come back.
Briefly, yeah.
Cllr Mark Roberts - 2:36:36
Just when will we be able to see a forecast of what the housing list is expected to look
like?
What would be a reasonable model of what the future housing list might look like and the
wait times that people might experience based on say for the next 10 years based
on what the expected the supply of new housings likely to be. I understand where
John Holman - Interim Service Director for Housing - 2:37:04
the question is coming from can I sort of take that away and we'll come back with a
Cllr Mark Roberts - 2:37:07
time frame for a time frame. Yeah yeah I'm not expecting that today but just
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:37:12
appreciate getting that information at some stage. Okay we'll note that in the
Cllr Caroline Cornell - 2:37:18
actions it's fine. I've got Councillor Cornell next. Actually thank you chair I
I think most of my questions have been asked,
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:37:20
so I'll leave it now, thank you.
That's my favourite kind of committee member.
Councillor Drayton.
Cllr Penny Drayton - 2:37:25
Thank you.
Two questions about locations, basically.
The first is in regards to,
we've got a geographic mobility across the county,
pretty picture graph in front of us.
Am I reading it correctly
that there was an allocation of 410 in Wickham that went down to 350. I just, I might not
be understanding it correctly, I'm just trying to understand if the allocation changed and
if so, why? What happened to those differences? Aylesbury increased which could be explained
by new housing but the others are fairly stable but Wickham seemed to lose 60 which I just,
I think I'm not understanding that graph.
The second question is in regards to families
that are looking for housing.
Now that it's opened up to the whole county
for applications, which is obviously portrayed
as a positive thing, which in many circumstances probably is,
it does raise an issue with families
that have school -aged children
who don't want to be applying across the whole county.
they very much want to stay in their area.
They don't have priority in their area
over anyone else now, I don't believe.
And I had a situation some time ago
where a family wasn't bidding on things
because it was really important to them
and their situation,
they had a lot of personal stuff going on
that they really wanted the stability for the children.
And I was told, well, they could apply
for somewhere in Aylesbury.
So I just want to understand the negative impact
that has come from given the possibility of opening
up the whole county for applications.
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:39:22
Thank you, Councillor Drayton.
I will answer the first question,
and Rachel will probably come in with the second.
So with the graph, I think it's item three, need appendix.
That's actually a graph to show the mobility across the county.
So it was trying to demonstrate
that within the Old Wycombe district area,
there had been 410 households, and it showed where they were,
have been rehoused since the new policy.
I mean, so 350 of those households were,
went into the old Wickham district area, whereas some
of them went into the Alesbury Vale,
the legacy Alesbury Vale area.
So it's actually showing, trying to demonstrate
where those households have actually moved to in the county
and whether there had been that cross -county mobility, which,
Did you want to come back on that one?
Thank you.
Cllr Penny Drayton - 2:40:11
It does display that.
I think I was just trying to understand if 410 homes have been moved from Wickham, but
only 350 placed in Wickham, why there's a difference there?
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:40:32
Some of those households have moved into other areas of books.
So not all, not the full 410 went into Wickham.
So some of those moved into the South Bucks area or some
of those moved into the Aylesbury area.
Sorry if I'm.
Cllr Penny Drayton - 2:40:48
Sorry, no, as I say, so just to be clear, it isn't 410
which were in housing, it could have been new applications.
Is that what we're saying?
Because I'm just trying to find where the disparity is that,
is it 410 original homes that have become 350?
So where have those other 60 gone?
Or is it just because this demonstrates new applications
who weren't in previous housing?
So I think the difference
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:41:18
of where we're speaking is this report,
so this diagram showing households.
So it's actually showing where people,
so applicants living in the Wickham area rather than houses,
so applicants living in the Wickham area,
where have they moved to post the implementation
of the new policy?
So some of those households stayed
in the Wickham district area,
so 350 of those households stayed.
Some of those households, though, out of that 410,
moved to different districts within the county.
Cllr Penny Drayton - 2:41:52
Thank you. I'm not going to go back. I was going to say I still don't quite get it, but can I follow up with you?
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:41:55
Yeah, well, I was just going to add. So I have to say it isn't the easiest graph to interpret.
In fact, it's pretty impossible to interpret, not least because you have to have it in colour for it to make any sense at all.
I also think when we put graphs like this in, and I think it's also true of the data, the so -whats of what you want the committee to focus in on is a really important part of it,
Because I think this could lead to quite a lot of confusion.
So you're not alone, I have to say, Councillor Drake,
in not finding this the easiest thing to understand.
So just for future, I think if we're going to use this diagram,
I think I wouldn't use this diagram to be honest,
but I would just find a different way of telling the storey
and what you want us to take from it and what it's saying.
And then your second question, I think you were going to pick up.
Cllr Penny Drayton - 2:42:35
Yeah, I'll pick up on that one.
So we tried with the local connexion approach,
obviously, to have it across the whole of Buckinghamshire
Rachel Emms-Davies - Housing Options Manager - 2:42:43
to give a simpler, more transparent scheme.
and obviously more consistent treatment of applicants
because we had a situation where if you were living
in the old Chiltern area and you bid on a property in Aylesbury,
you would have less priority for those properties even
if you had a high band if you didn't have a local connexion.
So we tried to make it more fair and equitable
and also increase homeless prevention
through the register as well.
So some families, and I appreciate it's not all of them,
some have very close and strong ties to particular areas,
But some people who are willing to move can then use those opportunities through Bucks home choice to bid in other areas if there's less
Available social housing in the area. They currently live in and we fully appreciate that doesn't work for everyone
It will only be a small number of applicants who it does benefit and work for
And I do hear what you're saying as well in terms of then there could be a perception with applicants who've living in those areas
That they feel disadvantaged
but we've obviously tried to look at the needs of everybody
and base it on housing need rather than just where somebody lives.
Thank you and as I say I appreciate the positive sides of it
Cllr Penny Drayton - 2:43:50
and that it does open up opportunities for more.
It's just what's not in the report is the feedback on
the negative sides because there will be an impact from those which are then
maybe taken off the register because they're not bidding, those which are
missing out on properties in their area because
somebody else has come in from out of area and I just want to understand a
negative side because the reality is there would be one but it's not talked
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:44:19
about and then you know to see what the balance is. Great thank you and finally
Cllr Dean Field - 2:44:23
Councillor Field. Thanks very much every time I think of a question somebody else
answers it so I'll try from another corner. So regarding private landlords is
Is there a shortage coming through?
And if there is, wouldn't that homeless figure then go up?
Are you seeing a trend that more people, private sector, are moving out the rental side?
Thank you, Councillor Fields.
Thomas Chettle - Head of Housing - 2:44:53
So it's interesting, in our homeless data at the moment, obviously, renters' rights
was implemented earlier in the year, and that abolished section 21 notices and did provide
lot more security to people living in private rentals.
For the last six months, we've seen a slight trend down in the amount of people being evicted
from the private sector coming into our homelessness front door.
And I think it's definitely too early to say if that's going to be a trend, which we continue
to see.
And it will be interesting to see the impact nationally as well as within Buckinghamshire.
I think the latter part is with landlords.
So we really, we've been working really hard with landlords,
private landlords in books.
And we've created a landlord forum to try
and give private landlords a voice and to try
and give them support in books.
And obviously, you know, help them, support them
with maintaining their tenants within their properties.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:45:51
Okay, thank you very much.
It's been a very thorough discussion.
And we've got a couple of actions
that we'll follow up on as well.
Thank you very much for your time everybody and I'm gonna move this quickly onto performance monitoring

8 Performance Monitoring Report Q2 2026 to 2027

I'm going to ask members conscious of time
Is there anything burning that anybody wants to ask a planning if not we can take questions separately and submit them
The cabinet member is anything anybody particularly wants to ask Gary was here
I'm gonna tell that tonight. Thank you very much
Missus to the work programme

9 Work Programme

So just to note the work programme. It's our attention at the next meeting to cover town centre regeneration
trading standards update and the Aylesbury housing infrastructure fund
project annual update members content with that because such really good
subject town centre regeneration if you've got any early sight of the nature
Cllr Robin Stuchbury - 2:46:42
of what that was going to be because we've done chunks of regeneration in
various areas and then there's areas of Buckinghamshire which haven't had any
regeneration, which you all know about.
And it's important that we gage where the future
investment's going to go because we can't keep
returning to the same areas.
We are a Buckinghamshire authority, not a –
Sure.
Will you be able to find out whether we got anything like that?
Because I'm doing – well, wearing a different hat.
I work with people locally who are working to promote
local trade and business. It's not my responsibility but I work with them if
you know what I mean. We all do those sort of things. I'd be very interested to
know if it's the Deputy Cabinet Member who's going to bring forward the
projections of where it's going to go or whether it's going to be a...
Yeah got it.
You know what I mean.
Cllr Simon Rouse - 2:47:39
I do. I totally got it. So the scope of that item is the existing Town Centre
regeneration project but I'm really happy to write to the Cabinet Member and
ask them as part of that to talk about what a future roadmap might look like
which I think is a fair question, so we can do that.
OK, I took that as agreed.
So thank you, firstly, members.
It's been a full -on agenda today,
and I think we've had a really good discussion and challenge.
And thank you, Steve, for sticking with us all the way
through to the end.

10 Date of Next Meeting

So the next meeting is on Tuesday, the 26th of January
at 10 AM and will take place in the Paralympic Room.
And given there is no further business,
I will close the meeting there.
I wish everybody a good day.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Thank you.
Webcast Finished - 2:48:19
Thank you.